Poetry Thursday: Allen Tate

From Poetry Foundation: Tate employed numerous classical allusions in his work; he also often wrote intensely personal poetry that would not reveal itself instantly to a reader. In the Sewanee Review, Cowan called Tate “the most difficult poet of the 20th century.” Brooks also noted, “Tate puts a great burden upon his reader. He insists that the reader himself, by an effort of his own imagination, cooperate with the poet to bring the violent metaphors and jarring rhythms into unity.” And Georgia Review contributor M.E. Bradford maintained that Tate, with “his preference for the lyric and for the agonized persona in that genre—along with the admiration which his ingenuities in the employment of all manner of strategies have together inspired—have confirmed his reputation for obscurity, allusive privacy, and consequent difficulty.”

Tate was born right at the end of the century: 1899-1979. Lots of his poems featured Poetry Foundation are long — several are composed of a series of sonnets. Here are a couple short poems of his that are public domain — not enough to judge the claim that he was “the most difficult poet of the 20th Century, I realize, but you can see what you think.

Edges

I’ve often wondered why she laughed

On thinking why I wondered so;

It seemed such waste that long white hands

Should touch my hands and let them go.

And once when we were parting there,

Unseen of anything but trees,

I touched her fingers, thoughtfully,

For more than simple niceties.

But for some futile things unsaid

I should say all is done for us;

Yet I have wondered how she smiled

Beholding what was cavernous.

****

****

****

Red Stains

In a pyloned desert where the scorpion reigns

My love and I plucked poppies breathing tales

Of crimes now long asleep, whose once–red stains

Dyed stabbing men, at sea with bloody sails.

The golden sand drowsed. There a dog yelped loud;

And in his cry rattled a hollow note

Of deep uncanny knowledge of that crowd

That loved and bled in winy times remote.

The poppies fainted when the moon came wide;

The cur lay still. Our passionate review

Of red wise folly dreamed on . . . She by my side

Stared at the Moon; and then I knew he knew.

       And then he smiled at her; to him ’twas funny—

       Her calm steel eyes, her earth–old throat of honey!

Please Feel Free to Share:

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

Poetry Thursday: Allen Tate Read More »

Recent Reading: This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me by Ilona Andrews

Okay, so This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me is the first new-to-me book I’ve read for quite some time, because I don’t read many novels while writing stuff of my own, especially not new-to-me novels. I really, really enjoyed it. So …

Rapid reactions first:

A) What a stupid title. Sorry! But my goodness, this title is not just LitRPG-ish, it is cartoonish. It’s like choosing to title a book The Good Guys Win or Space Opera 101: Raising the Stakes, or … I’m trying to think of other possible titles that hit me the same way … Let’s Get the Gang Together and Save the Barn. If Ilona Andrews was not already a famous name with tons of fans, I don’t think this would have worked. As it is, of course, it could be called Another Book by Ilona Andrews and plenty of people would have bought it.

B) The cover is not great. It looks like the animal is a giant long-necked bird, sort of like a goose, but with the head of an eagle.

Worse, like the title, it’s sort of cartoonish. If an animal looks sort of like a giant feathered greyhound with the neck of a swan and an eagle’s head, then DO IT LIKE THAT, and tell the artist, “Also, make it look poetic, evocative, real, not exaggerated or stylized, and if you don’t quite fit the description of the creature in the book, if I love your animal sufficiently, I’ll change the description to match, so strive for poetry in motion.”

Neither the cover nor the title seem to me to suit the feel of the book, which is far from cartoonish. It’s not LitRPG or even especially LitRPG-adjacent. It’s not really isekai either, I think, though much closer. Maybe it is isekai, but a novel that subverts a bunch of normal tropes. (Or what I gather the normal tropes are; I’m not that familiar with the genre personally.)

C) The story is great, generally speaking. It’s exactly what you would expect from Ilona Andrews, at the top end of their oeuvre. More on this essential point in a second. I will add here that a dramatis personae would have been useful.

D) There is a completely gratuitous cliffhanger in the epilogue. The main narrative resolves the story and provides a satisfying ending, and then the epilogue snatches the resolution away from the reader solely to create suspense for the sequel. Skip the epilogue and you’re golden. You can read the epilogue when Book Two comes out, as I assume it will, barring disaster.

Meanwhile, please, if you are writing a novel, do not do this. If you did a good job with the story, then readers will be happy to buy the second book. You do not need a dire cliffhanger on the last page in order to get them to buy it, so don’t put it there. Seriously, ugh, just do not do this. If you aren’t a NYT bestselling author, this kind of incredibly obvious manipulative trick will infuriate so many readers so much, they may decide they will never touch any other book you write, and you would deserve it.

***

Now, how about the actual story?

It is, as I say, great. While I think Ilona and Gordon Andrews are very talented, and they write in a way that reliably breaks me out of a (generally self-imposed) reading slump, I also think their books can be rather uneven. For example, I honestly did not think The Inheritance was all that and a bag of chips, even though I did like it. This one was a whole lot better. IMO, as I assume goes without saying, but, I mean, a lot better.

I will hand you the basic idea in a nutshell and then explain why it worked for me.

Maggie, an ordinary twenty-something woman living an ordinary life, is a superfan of an incomplete trilogy (last book never written). She has read the first two books many times and has them basically memorized, including the massive character list and all the nuances of who is related to whom, allied to whom, or enemies of whom, and why, and all the causality of what event leads to what outcome, and all the worldbuilding and political situation. This fictional story is very Game of Thrones-ish, with heaps of brutality and grit and ten thousand terrible things that happen to practically all the characters. The series sounds basically grimdark, though Maggie believes in her heart that it was heading for a just ending. (I have my doubts, based on what we learn about the story.)

Maggie wakes up in the world in the story. Because this world is brutal, she is starving, cold, friendless, and desperate. She tries to rob someone (he deserves it) and he kills her, and she wakes up again because she comes back to life when she is killed. This is the initial situation, so in fact the kingdom will kill her, and does, multiple times. However, at this point, she encounters a small act of kindness that allows her to take effective action to survive. We presume she would probably have come back to life again, but she doesn’t need to find out because she does manage to cope from this point on, and begins acting rather than just reacting, and using all her knowledge of the world and situation, and —

— This story is tremendous fun starting right there. It is exactly in line with Ilona Andrews’ previous work. Therefore, if you say to yourself, “I bet there is an incredibly sexy, powerful, domineering male lead,” you will be right. If you say, “I imagine there could be extremely powerful aristocrats and everybody else needs to run for cover,” you will once again be correct. If you think, “Hmm, I bet Maggie pets every puppy she finds cowering in the street,” of course she does, and naturally many of those “puppies” become handy allies. And, last, you will probably nod sagely when I say that enemies are powerful and the situation is dire and the good guys have to be clever and courageous to stop the looming disaster, which, yes.

So, what else can I say? Without spoiling anything other than the gratuitous cliffhanger in the epilogue? Hmm.

All right: Great plot twist that nobody is going to see coming, even if you are saying to yourself, “This element of early plot setup has GOT to lead to payoff; just how long is that going to take?” I really wondered about this. I was like, “This is Chekhov’s lucky coin right here, and where IS Chekhov?” Then there he was, and I practically screamed. This is the sort of plot twist that makes the reader want to re-read the book immediately, so they can enjoy anticipating this element.

Also, Maggie is a fine example of a Mary Sue protagonist done so well that readers love it rather than rolling their eyes (much).

Or is she? Because I might say she’s a Mary Sue or I might say she’s wish-fulfillment protagonist with a carefully limited superpower. That’s similar, but is it the same thing? Probably not quite.

Maggie is super-competent in exactly one way – she knows everything about everyone (more or less). Also, though her access to information gives her a tremendous advantage, it’s not the same as being inherently superior to everyone else. She is possibly a bit cleverer and more dedicated than reasonable, but that’s not only fine in a protagonist, it’s literally excellent in a protagonist, so no problems there.

Though Maggie’s position and influence increase over time, this doesn’t happen in a game-y sort of way at all. Also, you know what she does to both make and launder money? She invents modern soap. This is hilarious and plausible, not to mention almost enough all by itself to pull her out of Mary Sue territory.

Various extremely sexy and powerful guys fall for her. Why does this work?

Well, for one thing, Maggie does make important mistakes – important and understandable mistakes that are not stupid. For another, she is genuinely nice and brave, in realistic rather than over-the-top ways. In fact, she’s both nice and brave in exactly the way we would hope to be if we fell into our favorite grimdarkish fantasy novel and had to cope. Also, Ilona and Gordon are just so enormously skilled with this kind of character and bring her to life on the page. Readers are going to love Maggie. I loved Maggie. She is the perfect protagonist for a story like this.

Also, when various sexy, powerful guys fall for her, it’s not all of them. To be fair, although the effect is exaggerated because of who the guys are and how much space they take up, I think only two guys actually fall for Maggie. And one of them “falls in love” with an image in his head and the excitement of the chase, because Maggie is a Mystery Woman. Also, in a way, Solentine’s greatest use in the novel may be as The Important Male Character Who Doesn’t Fall In Love With Maggie. Instead, he frames a familial relationship with her, and thank heaven for that. I like Solentine a lot. He might be my favorite character.

Therefore, though Maggie is pretty Mary Sue-ish, this novel offers something other than the wish-fulfilment of entering your favorite fantasy novel, something more than that – it offers the wish-fulfilment of stepping into a favorite fantasy novel and saving all the characters you love from the terrible things you know are coming. With tension ratcheting upward as the horrible grimdark endings keep persistently threatening as you shove against the terrible future. Then, final victory against the odds.

So, overall:

Strengths:

Great protagonist, perfectly suited to the story.

Effective characterization, as long as you’re okay with one more exceedingly sexy, powerful, dangerous male lead. (I am, apparently, as long as he’s also well written and placed in an appropriate setting and story.) By “effective characterization” here, I mean “really well suited to the story,” because there are a multitude of characters and they are mostly fairly flat, but they work in this story. This would be a good choice to read if you wanted to see skillfully drawn, simple characters.

Extremely fun storytelling and clever plotting, including a really stunning plot twist; masterful control of tension; lively style; witty dialogue.

Good guys win, barely.

Weaknesses:

That godforsaken epilogue. Just skip it, that’s my sincere advice, and read it when the second book comes out.

Lack of a dramatis personae and possibly a glossary. Considering there are great heaping gobs of named characters, many with titles or positions, plus heaps of magical creatures and lots of locations, a list of names and terms in the back would have been really useful.

Quibbles:

One jarring “he and I, him and me” error. A couple of typos. One sentence that’s so confusing I couldn’t figure it out, so I suspect it’s debris left from revision. Only the most observant readers are going to notice any of this, I realize.

Cartoonish presentation via cover and title does not suit the story.

Please Feel Free to Share:

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

Recent Reading: This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me by Ilona Andrews Read More »

Honestly, the Natural World is Weird

Nature never developed wheels, right? Hoop snakes are folk tales.

Pecos Bill, a legendary cowboy in American folklore, is said to have encountered the fearsome hoop snake during one of his many wild adventures. Despite the hoop snake’s deadly reputation, with its venomous tail capable of withering trees with a single strike, Pecos Bill, known for his extraordinary feats, managed to outsmart and tame the snake before sending it rolling off into the horizon. However, this is just one of many tall tales about the cowboy who allegedly lassoed a tornado and rode it like a bucking bronco, further cementing his status as the ultimate larger-than-life figure in American folklore.

So, that’s the hoop snake.

Now, meet the dwarf reed snake.

A snake starts by curling its body into a tight curve, with its head lifted off the ground facing the direction of travel. As the snake rolls along the ground like a wheel, its body begins to straighten out and the point where it touches the ground shifts toward its tail. The animal then pushes off the ground with its tail, launching itself into the air. While briefly airborne, the creature twists into an S-shape, forming an arch above its head. It then swings this arch forward and down past one side of its head until that side of its body hits the ground. That contact starts the next cartwheel, allowing the snake to keep rolling forward while alternating which side of its body strikes the ground.

There’s a video and more detailed explanation at the link. I would not describe this motion as “rolling along the ground like a wheel,” because I’ve never seen a wheel bounce this much without hitting, you know, a bump, but this is still remarkable.

Previously, I only knew about cartwheeling spiders.

Please Feel Free to Share:

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

Honestly, the Natural World is Weird Read More »

Update: Several Steps Forward, Followed by a Pause

All right, so last week went like this:

A) Working on Haokaal (probable title), by writing bits and pieces completely out of order. Every now and then, I write a book by starting somewhere random and moving back and forth, and I guess this will be one of those, at least for now. I’ll probably start moving more in chronological order eventually. I mean, usually I do.

Yes, by the way, my intention is to title every book in this internal series with a word beginning with H, in order to help readers (and me) remember which books belong to this particular series within the larger Tuyo series.

B) And then proofing and copyedits arrived for inKera, so I stopped dead with Haokaal, shifted back to inKera, and did great heaping gobs of incredibly boring proofing and tweaking, plus the last bit of teensy revision. And the weekend disappeared, poof!

The good news there is: I think this is about the final-final-final version, and I’m going to load everything to KDP and also make an epub file. I may drop inKera at my Patreon tomorrow, at the Early Access Tier. If not tomorrow, then Wednesday or probably not later than Thursday.

The bad news is: Sigh, I bet there will be a few more corrections, and now each correction will have to be made to FOUR DIFFERENT FILES. Not only is this tedious, but every now and then, for reasons that are truly difficult to understand, a specific correction gets made to SOME of the versions, but not ALL of the versions, and then someone trips over a remaining typo that exists only in the paperback or only in the epub. This is exceedingly annoying. I honestly do have all four version open and go through each one making each correction and then double-checking to make sure I made the correction in each and every file, and with all that, you’d think nothing would ever slip through the cracks. But you would be wrong. I don’t understand how it happens, but it does.

Also, if you wonder why typos still exist at this point, there are two reasons. Three.

  1. No matter what you do, it’s impossible to get them all.
  2. When I add a paragraph or make a tiny revision, I may create a brand new typo no one has ever seen before, and these are astoundingly difficult to see. I found a typo of that sort by just randomly stumbling over it this morning.
  3. Typos magically appear in pristine prose. This is a fact.

However, I hope there are, at this point, very few typos left in this book.

MEANWHILE

I dropped the story with Gyo and Teyet into my newsletter in just two installments, two chapters at a time, because it just seemed to work better that way. Therefore, I need a new story / scene / letter / vignette / something to drop in my newsletter for December. This is not a problem, because I have nigh unto infinite ideas, after all. I think it’ll be an alternate pov scene from Tarashana, the bit where Geras finds himself in the starlit land and stops Ryo from possibly beating Aras to death, from Geras’ pov. I don’t know if that will be a complete enough story to add to a story collection. Perhaps I’ll ask newsletter subscribers what they think.

MEANWHILE

I read a book! First time I’ve read a new-to-me book for a good long time. (I’ve been re-reading this and that) (Foreigner books and Jennifer Crusie books, mostly). So I’ll post about that later.

And I should be picking up Haokaal again tomorrow, though probably not today. It’s a tiny embryonic novel right now, 12,000 words, but these words are divided among four different scenes, none of which are complete. It’s certainly an odd way to approach a novel. We’ll see how it goes!

Please Feel Free to Share:

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

Update: Several Steps Forward, Followed by a Pause Read More »

50 Favorite Novels

I started to put together a list of 50 favorite authors. This turned out to be impossible. Some authors have written heaps of novels I love, while other authors have written exactly one novel I love, yet I still wanted to put them on my list. Therefore, what I actually did was reframe this idea as “50 favorite novels, each by a different author, many of whom are among my favorite authors.”

Sometimes, for some authors, picking a favorite work was all but impossible. Which of CJC’s books is REALLY my actual favorite? This is impossible.

For other authors, the book I name is a great favorite of mine, even if the author has never written more than a couple of books, or has only written one book that I especially love.

MOST of the time, I’m forcing myself to name one and only one title per author, and thus for some authors, you can assume I threw a dart at their bibliography. Or I might have named the first book of the series I love best. OR, it’s MY list, and it’s not the boss of me, and therefore now and then I do name a full series rather than a single book. Also, If I name a book I really love, but which is not available in ebook form (as far as I can tell), then I may also name a second book by that author which I ALSO love and which IS available in ebook form.

Though there’s a strong bias toward SFF authors, you’ll see a scattering of other genres are represented.

  1. “Katherine Addison” — The Goblin Emperor. This is one of the authors on this list who wrote one stellar novel that I love and have read many times, plus various other novels that I don’t like nearly as much. If I ever take time to write fanfic, then a direct sequel to The Goblin Emperor is one of the fanfic novels I would most like to write. The audiobook is great and the narrator makes those amazing names sound easy and natural.
  2. Richard Adams — Watership Down. Adams never wrote anything else I really liked. But Watership Down is so fabulous that I had to include it.
  3. Ilona Andrews — Burn for Me. Yes, lots of contenders, but this series is great from top to bottom. For me, the Innkeeper series is too silly, while the Kate Daniels series is somewhat uneven. Here, each and every book is great, including this one, even though the setup didn’t sound like it would appeal to me when I read the description. I especially like the solid families. Lots of characters, but I’m glad Ilona Andrews went to the trouble to include a bigger family that is a pleasure to read about.
  4. Peter Beagle — The Last Unicorn, obviously.
  5. Gillian Bradshaw — Island of Ghosts, and for one of the few times on this list, I’m going to mention a second title: Beacon at Alexandria. I was going to put Beacon first, but there’s no ebook edition! So I picked one of my other favorites to go first, but if you don’t hate paper editions, then it was hard to pick one or the other, but I really love Beacon.
  6. Marie Brennan — Memoirs of Lady Trent. This is such a fabulous series. It captures the attitude and style of Nineteenth Century British naturalists, toned down and shifted sideways a bit to make the attitudes a hair more consistent with modern attitudes. Also, the cover art, which is absolutely stellar, also evokes the work of naturalists. And on top of that, Marie Brennan is such a skilled author. Not all her work appeals to me, but I can always see the skill she brings to her novels, even if I don’t necessarily like them. (I’m thinking of Midnight Never Come here. I think that series struck me as claustrophobic, with characters more or less trapped in bad circumstances, a setup that pushes me away from a novel. I’m not swearing to that, but I think that was the issue.) Regardless, some of the later books of the Lady Trent series are perhaps not wholly plausible, but the whole series is fun to read and I certainly recommend it.
  7. Sarah Rees Brennan — Demon’s Lexicon. This is a very, very intense trilogy. Ultra intense. It is also extremely good, with fabulous characters and dialogue, great plotting, honestly, if you haven’t read it, don’t let the word “intense” turn you off. I have never (yet) read anything else by Brennan. I HAVE other books of hers, and I hear they are good. I’m sure they are, and now, thinking about this trilogy, I’m also thinking: What’s wrong with me? Obviously I should pull others of her books up to the top of my TBR pile and read them! I suspect that the sheer intensity of the Demon’s Lexicon has made me hesitate, because they are not books to read when you need to concentrate on other things.
  8. Steven Brust — Jhereg. You know what, if someone is asking, “What is a character’s voice, anyway? What is meant by “a character with strong voice?”, they could look at this series. I know I’ve either heard, or maybe used myself, a specific term for this kind of first person — First Person Smartass. Also, I have a particular liking for fictional assassins, provided they are more on the heart-of-gold side of the spectrum rather than the vicious-sociopath side of the spectrum. They don’t have to be actually nice, but if they pat the occasional puppy, I do prefer that. Vlad is great. (Usually great.)
  9. Lois McMaster Bujold — The Curse of Chalion. It is, of course, hard to choose any one of LMB’s novels (or novellas) to feature here. So, here is one, not quite at random, and I could have picked six others. Also, back when I was juuuuust beginning to write fiction, guess whose novels I picked up to look at dialogue tags? I remember that clearly. I went to the Vorkosigan novels. So, when I tried to think of an author who handled dialogue really well, LMB was the one who leaped to mind first.
  10. Octavia Butler — Xenogenesis trilogy. I will always regret that I never had the chance to sit down with Octavia Butler and say, “So, the most important difference between the oankali and humans is that the oankali have important instincts that are far, far more hardwired. Unlike humans, who have a plethora of competing instincts that mean no single instinct is truly hardwired and irresistible, the oankali are truly subject to a handful of identifiable and unitary instincts that mandate specific behavior. Did you do that on purpose?” Also, this trilogy is intense, but in a completely different way than the Demon’s Lexicon trilogy.
  11. C. J. Cherryh — Chanur’s Legacy. This last book in the series works great as a standalone and showcases the splendid aliens in a story that is more fun rather than maximally intense. Also, I’m going to mention a second book, for the same reason as before: Cyteen, which is not available as an ebook.
  12. Susanna Clarke — Piranesi. Wow, is this a beautiful book. Yes, Clarke’s super long and ambitious JS&MrN is impressive, but Piranesi is the one I’ve read three times and listened to once. So far.
  13. Susan Cooper — The Dark Is Rising. Yes, the whole series ends with an iffy “and then they forgot everything” thing. However, first, the whole series is worth reading anyway, and second, The Dark is Rising is the best book in the series.
  14. Jennifer Crusie — Welcome to Temptation. I’ve enjoyed everything I’ve read by Crusie or Crusie / Meyer, and I couldn’t decide what to pick, so I picked this one because it was the first of hers I read. Big backlist still ahead of me.
  15. Dorothy Dunnett — The Lymond series. This amazing series taught me a lot about writing, and also directly inspired the Death’s Lady series by making me want to write a story where I separated the protagonist from the pov character. She impressed me so much by doing that, and it was such a great way to change how tension was handled in the series.
  16. Kate Elliott — Jaran. Gracious, this is a terrible cover. Sorry! But I do think it’s terrible. The price, however, is excellent and if you’ve never read this book and you’re in the mood for an immersive fatasy-esque SF novel, here you go. Kate Elliott never finished this series, which therefore peters out and does not really conclude. Jaran, the first book, is a satisfying standalone.
  17. Laura Florand — The Chocolate Kiss. Not sure which of Florand’s (contemporary romance) novels is my favorite, but this one is jostling for first place. They can all be read as standalones. I’m sorry Florand stopped writing, but I understand her life got crazy busy. Maybe when she retires from her Real Job, she’ll start writing again? I would be there for that.
  18. Victoria Goddard — The Hands of the Emperor. You all know how much I love this huge and sprawling novel.
  19. Rumer Godden — In This House of Brede. I love this book so much. I guess I’m compelled to call it Literary for lack of a better term, but it is nothing like the contemporary-setting depressive-protagonist novels I think of as “Typical Literary.” It was published in 1969, so maybe that’s why it seems so utterly different from (most) modern literary novels. Rumer Godden was a contemporary of Pearl Buck, and I think their books share … not style, not plot, not setting … perhaps a sensibility that is fundamentally optimistic rather than the pessimistic, nihilistic sensibility that is common in literary today.
  20. Nicola Griffith — The Blue Place. I know a lot of people think of Hild first, and it is admittedly very impressive. But for me, the Aud novels are difficult to knock out of first place. The protagonist is also the best-drawn sensualist character I have ever seen in fiction.
  21. Barbara Hambly — A Free Man of Color. Grim grim grim in setting, 1830 New Orleans, so this is one of the historical novels where setting is everything. Except it’s not everything, because the characters are everything. Honestly, Hambly is at her absolute best here. Her settings can take over her novels, but not in this one, because the characters are so well-drawn and the plot is also brisk and surprising.
  22. Georgette Heyer — Cotillion. This is probably my favorite of Heyer’s, mostly because Freddie is such a great male lead.
  23. Nina Kiriki Hoffman — A Fistful of Sky. This is my favorite of Hoffman’s books, and also it’s interesting because it reads like YA, even though the protagonist is twenty-four, and thinking about why is, as I say, interesting.
  24. Andrea K Höst — The Touchstone Trilogy. Surely you’ve all read this? I’ve read it a million times and listened to the audiobook version at least twice. Also, anybody remember AKH week? Lot of great posts during that week.
  25. Barry Hughart — Bridge of Birds. An utterly charming fantasy trilogy.
  26. Diana Wynne Jones — Dogsbody. My very favorite DWJ novel, and also, I still can’t believe she made it work. The Wild Hunt, anthropomorphized stars, the painful situation of the Irish protagonist, and all through a dog’s eye view. More or less.
  27. Guy Gavriel Kay — Under Heaven. I hesitated over which of GGK’s novels to pick. I think the ending here is too abrupt; I think Kay should have just continued for another fifty pages and tied things off properly. But … it’s really beautiful. The beginning is especially beautiful and perfect in every way. When I think: Books by GGK, hmm, this one just leaps to mind. Thus, here it is.
  28. Rosemary Kirstein — The Steerswoman series. The single best unfinished series ever. I really, honestly might eventually sit down and write the last book myself and drop it on Archive of Our Own or something, because I can hardly bear leaving this series unfinished. Regardless, very much worth reading even though it does not come to a conclusion.
  29. Ann Leckie — The Ancillary Justice trilogy. A stunning trilogy. Honestly, fabulous. I do wonder whether it was an inspiration for Murderbot. Breq is similar to Murderbot in several ways, but even less in touch with its own feelings and motivations. Hard to believe Leckie pulled off the ending in this trilogy, which only works because of how she handled Breq’s obliviousness about its own motivations and even intentions.
  30. Patrick Lee — The Breach trilogy. A stellar thriller trilogy. A graduate class in how to handle pacing and shocking plot twists.
  31. R. A. MacAvoy — The Lens of the World. So many options! But it pushed a lot of my buttons and has stuck with me for a long time.
  32. Juliet Marillier — Daughter of the Forest. Lovely writing, beautiful retelling.
  33. Patricia McKillip — The Changeling Sea. Wait, did I say “lovely writing” already? This is one of the most perfect little gems I can think of.
  34. Robin McKinley — The Blue Sword. What a great writer McKinley was. She’s the single best example I can think of, of an author who just makes the prose look effortless and transparent. The reader just falls right into the story. Yet it’s not necessarily conversational either. She actually uses different syntax for the different societies. I never thought of her in this context, but I might have learned that partly from her. This is the first of her novels I ever read, and still holds a special place in my heart.
  35. China Mieville — The City and the City. I don’t like everything by Mieville, which isn’t surprising because he writes radically different books. The one I keep going back to is this one.
  36. Naomi Novik — Scholomance trilogy. One of the all-time great YA trilogies ever written. Best, most likable “unlikeable” protagonist ever.
  37. Terry Pratchett — Night Watch. This was the first Pratchett book that worked for me — because I didn’t like The Colour of Magic and never read much of his, and then many years later read Night Watch. It was, as you can imagine, a revelation. Sam Vimes is still my favorite.
  38. Marta Randall — Mapping Winter. Randall wrote Sword of Winter, bowed to editorial pressure to make the ending rather too pat, and eventually heavily revised the book into Mapping Winter, which does come across as more sophisticated, deeper. You can see Randall grew as a writer between those two books.
  39. Eluki bes Shahar — Hellflower. Such absolutely fabulous style. Wow. One of the best novel openings in the history of SF.
  40. Sharon Shinn — The Shapechanger’s Wife. Another perfect gem.
  41. Sherwood Smith — Tribute. Wow, do I love this book — which, unlike most of Smith’s, stands alone perfectly.
  42. Mary Stewart — Merlin series; she might as well have aimed this book directly at me.
  43. “James Tiptree Jr” — Up the Walls of the World. One of my favorite-ever alien species. I barely noticed the human plotline the first however many times I read this book. I was all about those aliens.
  44. J. R. R. Tolkien — The Lord of the Rings. Because of course.
  45. Megan Whalen Turner — The Queen of Attolia. Honestly, it’s hard for me to choose between this one and The King of Attolia. What a splendid series, and how wildly different the books are. A graduate course in pov.
  46. Ursula Vernon / “T Kingfisher” — The Twisted Ones. I know! Picking a horror novel, who saw that coming! But this is probably my favorite! If the frame story hadn’t lowered tension by making it clear the dog did not die (nor the main character), it would have been impossible. With that assurance, it was fine.
  47. Martha Wells — The Cloud Roads. I know she won everything for Murderbot, and sure, yes, I see that. But the first Raksura trilogy is my actual favorite of Wells’ books and I don’t think that’s going to change. This book stands alone perfectly. Great cover art, too.
  48. Elizabeth Wein — Code Name Verity. Historical. Brilliantly written. Wein is extremely gifted. In the massive subgenre of WWII historicals, nobody does it better. Emotionally devastating, ultimately positive in tone.
  49. Andy Weir — The Martian. Just so clever and catchy. And so interesting because the protagonist has no character arc whatsoever, thus serving as a fabulous example of a successful novel where the protagonist does not have a character arc.
  50. Patricia Wrede — Mairelon the Magician. Very, very hard to choose. This story is nicely put together, and there is a scene at the end that really gets me, and that’s possibly why I picked this one.

Whew!

Putting together this list was harder than I expected! I was really torn for some of these! I’m sure I’ve left out some authors I absolutely should have included, and I’m equally sure that some of you would have picked completely different books by some of these authors. I know for sure Kim would NEVER have picked The Twisted Ones!

So, tell me! Which authors should I have included? If you could recommend just ONE book by an author I left out, what would it be?

Please Feel Free to Share:

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

50 Favorite Novels Read More »

Poetry Thursday: The golden Journey to Samarkand

James Elroy Flecker, 1884-1915. I know nothing about him. At All Poetry, we see a little bit of biography: His verses were greatly influenced by the French style Parnassism which grew out of the positivist movement of the early 19th century and, despite his short life, he wrote a number of collections the most memorable being The Golden Journey to Samarkand.

This is actually a play, which you can download at Project Gutenberg, if you like. From Project Gutenberg: Hassan: the story of Hassan of Bagdad, and how he came to make the golden journey to Samarkand” by James Elroy Flecker is a play in five acts written during the early 20th century. The narrative revolves around Hassan, a humble confectioner in Baghdad, who finds himself entwined in a tumultuous pursuit of love and respect. The story explores the dynamics of ambition, enchantment, and the complexities of human desire against a vividly portrayed Middle Eastern backdrop. …

Where is Samarkand, anyway? Here’s a Wikipedia article. There is evidence of human activity in the area of the city dating from the late Paleolithic. Although the exact date of Samarkand’s founding remains uncertain, it has been proposed that the city was established between the 8th and 7th centuries BC. Historically, Samarkand has long been one of the principal urban centres of Iranic civilisation in Central Asia and played a major role in the cultural and commercial networks of the Silk Road.

Here’s a bit of this play —


PROLOGUE


We who with songs beguile your pilgrimage
And swear that Beauty lives though lilies die,
We Poets of the proud old lineage
Who sing to find your hearts, we know not why, –
What shall we tell you? Tales, marvellous tales
Of ships and stars and isles where good men rest,
Where nevermore the rose of sunset pales,
And winds and shadows fall towards the West:
And there the world’s first huge white-bearded kings
In dim glades sleeping, murmur in their sleep,
And closer round their breasts the ivy clings,
Cutting its pathway slow and red and deep.


THE GOLDEN JOURNEY TO SAMARKAND

EPILOGUE


At the Gate of the Sun, Baghdad, in olden time


THE MERCHANTS :
Away, for we are ready to a man!
Our camels sniff the evening and are glad.
Lead on, O Master of the Caravan:
Lead on the Merchant-Princes of Baghdad.


THE CHIEF DRAPER :
Have we not Indian carpets dark as wine,
Turbans and sashes, gowns and bows and veils,
And broideries of intricate design,
And printed hangings in enormous bales?


THE CHIEF GROCER :
We have rose-candy, we have spikenard,
Mastic and terebinth and oil and spice,
And such sweet jams meticulously jarred
As God’s own Prophet eats in Paradise.


THE PRINCIPAL JEWS :
And we have manuscripts in peacock styles
By Ali of Damascus; we have swords
Engraved with storks and apes and crocodiles,
And heavy beaten necklaces, for Lords.


THE MASTER OF THE CARAVAN :
But you are nothing but a lot of Jews.

THE PRINCIPAL JEWS :
Sir, even dogs have daylight, and we pay.

THE MASTER OF THE CARAVAN :
But who are ye in rags and rotten shoes,
You dirty-bearded, blocking up the way?


THE PILGRIMS :
We are the Pilgrims, master; we shall go
Always a little further: it may be
Beyond the last blue mountain barred with snow,
Across that angry or that glimmering sea,
White on a throne or guarded in a cave
There lives a prophet who can understand
Why men were born: but surely we are brave,
Who take the golden road to Samarkand.


THE CHIEF MERCHANT :
We gnaw the nail of hurry. Master, away!

ONE OF THE WOMEN :
O turn your eyes to where your children stand.
Is not Baghdad the beautiful? O stay!

THE MERCHANTS in chorus :
We take the Golden Road to Samarkand.


AN OLD MAN :
Have you not girls and garlands in your homes,
Eunuchs and Syrian boys at your command?
Seek not excess: God hateth him who roams!

THE MERCHANTS :
We take the golden road to Samarkand.


A PILGRIM WITH A BEAUTIFUL VOICE :
Sweet to ride forth at evening from the wells
When shadows pass gigantic on the sand,
And softly through the silence beat the bells
Along the Golden Road to Samarkand.


A MERCHANT :
We travel not for trafficking alone:
By hotter winds our fiery hearts are fanned:
For lust of knowing what should not be known
We take the golden road to Samarkand.


THE MASTER OF THE CARAVAN :
Open the gate, O watchman of the night!

THE WATCHMAN :
Ho, travellers, I open. For what land
Leave you the dim-moon city of delight?


THE MERCHANTS (with a shout)
We take the golden road to Samarkand.


(The Caravan passes through the gate)

THE WATCHMAN (consoling the women)
What would ye, ladies? It was ever thus.
Men are unwise and curiously planned.

A WOMAN :
They have their dreams, and do not think of us.

VOICES OF THE CARAVAN : (in the distance, singing)
We take the golden road to Samarkand.


Photo by Sultonbek Ikromov on Unsplash

Image by LoggaWiggler from Pixabay

Please Feel Free to Share:

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

Poetry Thursday: The golden Journey to Samarkand Read More »

StoryScope: Looking at Narrative in Generated Stories

Here is a readable version of this StoryScope article, which describes an attempt to sort out AI-generated stories not on stylistic grounds, but on higher-level characteristics, such as “discourse-level narrative choices such as character agency and chronological discontinuity.” This is really interesting, and many thanks to commenter MJ for drawing my attention to this experiment.

This article begins this way: AI fiction is already under our noses. In March 2026, Hachette, a major publishing house, pulled the horror novel Shy Girl after it was flagged as ∼78% AI-generated, the first commercially published novel canceled over AI allegations. Nearly 20% of a sample of 14,000 self-published Amazon novels were flagged by Pangram as largely AI-generated, a figure that jumped 41% year-over-year. Overall, readers are increasingly being misled into purchasing AI-generated books attributed to human authors. If authors are unwilling to self-disclose AI usage, how can we address this issue?

And here are the main points, drawn from the abstract of the article, which I’m presenting here in bulleted form because that’s so much easier to read than a brick of text.

Can AI-generated fiction be distinguished from human-written fiction based on narrative choices rather than writing style? Previous research has focused primarily on stylistic signals, such as word choice and sentence structure. StoryScope instead examines narrative features, such as character agency, plot structure, and chronology.

Dataset:

  • 10,272 writing prompts, each used to produce one human-written story and five AI-generated stories.
  • Five AI models: Claude, DeepSeek, Gemini, GPT, and Kimi.
  • 61,608 stories total, approximately 5,000 words each.

The researchers started with 10,272 existing human-written short stories, then used Gemini to reverse-engineer a premise from each story. They gave those reconstructed prompts to the five AI models and generated a whole whopping lot more stories, and then they examined the original human-written stories compared to the generated stories. I’m pretty sure that’s right.

I’m pausing here to say: someone REALLY needs to look at NOVELS, which are qualitatively different from short stories, especially quite short stories of 5000 words, which is about 15 pages, so I mean, these are short. I immediately conclude the researchers are (a) not novelists, and (b) did not ask a novelist for opinions about their study design. Or, I mean, if they did, the novelists they asked did not say, as I would have: The distinction between short stories and longer works is much more important than I think you may have allowed for in your design. You are essentially certain to find that AI-generation is much more suited to the generation of short stories, the shorter the better, rather than novels. For example, and this is just one of infinite possible examples, a novelist can set up information in chapter two that then pays off in a thoroughly unexpected way in chapter twenty. This happens all the time! The author has to set up what the reader knows, what each character knows, what each character believes other characters know, and how all those states change over time — and then create a satisfying payoff based on setup the reader noticed, but that wasn’t so blatant the reader exclaimed, “Hello, Mr. Chekov!” when they saw it. This is a TREMENDOUSLY more demanding task than anything you’re going to see in a short story, and novels are FILLED TO THE BRIM with this kind of complicated stuff. I’m sure we could all sit here for an hour explaining the many ways that novels are far more complicated than fifteen-page short stories.

I grant, short stories are easier to work with, which does not mean they are the best items to look at. I think nonfiction essays (Substack style) and novels are both much more relevant to discussions about generated prose, because both are just more numerous and (I’m pretty sure) have a lot more money involved than short stories. So, I see why these researchers chose to work with short stories, but honestly, I would rather see a smaller dataset of novels than a giant dataset of short stories.

However, here’s what they found:

Detection accuracy:

  • Using narrative features alone, StoryScope achieved >90% success when distinguishing human-written from AI-generated stories.
  • It achieved nearly 70% success when identifying which of the six sources (five AI models or a human) produced a story.
  • Narrative features were sufficient to accomplish classification, even when stylistic features were excluded from the analysis.
  • Thirty core narrative features captured much of the difference between human and AI fiction.

Ah, thirty features! I bet the statistics looks pretty complicated. Oh, these percentages are “macro-F1 scores,” not simple percentages? All right, I looked it up, and evidently a “macro-F1 score” combines two measures of classification performance, then averages the results across categories. The point of using this statistic is to prevent the much larger number of AI-generated stories from dominating the score. However, what matters here is, these scores mean the researchers achieved clear, strong separation between human and AI stories in their dataset. That’s enough for me; I’m not doing any kind of deep dive into macro-F1 vs F1 vs anything else.

Anyway, what were some of those narrative features?

  • Themes are explained more explicitly. The narrator tends to comment explicitly on the theme, the dialogue delivers the theme, the resolution emphasizes understanding or acceptance.
  • Plots tend to be tidy, straightforward, and focused on a single narrative track, with emotional and thematic conflict explicitly resolved.
  • Stories tend to occupy a relatively narrow range of narrative possibilities, with the protagonist generally driving the resolution.

These stories were only 5000 words long! How many narrative tracks do you expect to see in a story that short? And who else should drive the resolution, if not the protagonist? However, no, apparently in generated stories, the protagonist drove the resolution nearly 70% of the time, and in human-authored stories, this was true less than 50% of the time.

Common characteristics of human-written stories:

  • Protagonists’ choices are presented with greater moral ambiguity.
  • Stories exhibit greater temporal complexity, including flashbacks and nonlinear structures.
  • Narrative choices are more diverse overall.
  • More frequently “unusual” — showing features unusual compared to “neighboring” stories.

All right, so more stories featured complicated narrative structures than I would have expected. Also, the StoryScope study does include factors I consider stylistic, such as use of all five senses, and “show don’t tell” hammering heartbeats and clammy palms and all the rest of the overdone show-show-show physicality. ChatGPT tells me chatbots get this from all the bad show-don’t-tell writing advice online, and I would bet people who “trained” AI chatbots don’t understand how stupid the hammering heartbeats get, or why and when it’s better to say, “He was afraid.” Also, human-written stories contain a whole lot more specific cultural references, as one would expect. Again, I’d call that stylistic, not structural. This conflation of narrative features and stylistic features weakens the central premise of the study, imo.

Do all AI Chatbots tend to handle fiction the same way?

  • Claude: Relatively flat escalation of events.
  • GPT: Frequent use of gossip as a plot mechanism.
  • Gemini: A tendency toward external descriptions of characters.
  • Gemini, DeepSeek, and Kimi tend to produce stories roughly half as long as the human originals (even when directed to aim for equivalent lengths).

Overall finding: AI-generated stories cluster together in a shared region of narrative possibilities, while human-written stories exhibit greater narrative diversity. Main conclusion: Differences in how stories are constructed—not merely differences in prose style—can help distinguish human-written fiction from AI-generated fiction.

Also, there’s no reason to think that this analysis would generalize successfully to commercial fiction, future AI models, different prompting practices, or human authors using AI tools as, say, a writing prosthetic.

Also, this study has very little to say about NOVELS, seriously, that is a major problem for generalizing most of the conclusions reached by this study. If someone tried to generate a novel, as I’m sure many people are, I would not be surprised if it turned out to be 100,000 words of repetitive description, dialogue, and emotional beats sprinkled through loosely connected or unconnected or pointlessly drawn-out events. A whole bunch of repetitive words would be a lot easier to generate than an actual novel. And it does seem to me that LLMs always want to reach pat resolutions as fast as possible, so maybe also a repeated tendency to try to do that, even though there are 96,000 words to go, so resolving everything right now at the 4000-word mark is a bad idea.

How about looking at features such as persistence of character style and transformation of character motivations, the plausible development of relationships, the successful integration of the plot arc with the relationship arc, long-term causality — I mean plot setup leading to payoff — and the existence and number of apparently unrelated narrative threads that eventually converge. Those are all narrative features rather than stylistic features, so how about those?

StoryScope is asking, “Do AI-generated short stories make different narrative choices than human writers make when writing short stories?” This is an interesting question, but it’s not quite the same as asking, “Can AI successfully use and manage the kinds of narrative choices that make novels work?” I vote for “No, not yet,” but I don’t think anybody is looking at that. Or maybe they are and I haven’t heard about it! I hadn’t heard of this StoryScope thing until commenter MJ mentioned it. If someone knows about a study looking at actual generated novels, please mention it. I know of at least one person who has generated lots of (short!) novels and put them on Amazon, and since I have figured out where to find examples, I should post about that some time.

Meanwhile, you can click through and read the whole thing about StoryScope yourself if you wish.

Please Feel Free to Share:

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

StoryScope: Looking at Narrative in Generated Stories Read More »

Historical Fiction

From Emma Darwin’s This Itch of Writing: Ten Things That Go Wrong With Historical Fiction

This post is “quick round-up of the most common things that go wrong in the historical fiction that I see in students’ work, in published fiction and, of course, my own early draft,” says Emma, and then lists ten “things that go wrong,” each with a brief discussion.

Here’s her first point:

Thinking that good research is the key to good writing. It isn’t. Good technique is the key to good writing, whereas good research is merely necessary, not sufficient.

This is exactly like the (exceedingly common) delusion that a great idea is the key to a great SF novel, when in fact good technique is the key to good writing. In SF, the idea is sometimes keen, but not necessary, and by no means sufficient.

Oh, here’s a neat one —

Titles and Forms of Address. If you don’t know why novelist Harriet Vane’s married name is Lady Peter Wimsey, when her married sister-in-law is Lady Mary Parker, but the wife of Sir Harry Smith is Juana, Lady Smith, then please don’t put a famous general or a duke’s offspring in your novel. I don’t give a toss for the peerage’s feelings, but I do give a great many tosses for getting things right, out of respect for my readers and to help them to make that crucial trust-fall. This is a quick summary, this post is super-helpful, and author Philip Womack here explains why what sounds like a ridiculously arcane bit of fogeyish fussery actually matters. It helps to sink into Georgette Heyer’s worlds: she never writes ‘my lord’ when the character should say ‘your lordship’, or ‘madame’ for ‘madam’.

Gosh, I’m going to have to click through and look at her “quick summary.”

All her points look good, especially … well, especially several others, in fact, but I will pull out one more:

No sense of the religious dimension of life and society. One of the main drivers for writing for The Bruegel Boy was my sense that how faith drives people (as opposed to how different tribes get formed round faith identities) doesn’t get explored often in historical fiction. It’s incredibly difficult for 21st century humans to imagine themselves into a society where it never occurs to almost anyone that there just is nothing beyond the realm of material reality. 

It’s not that difficult, actually. Or it shouldn’t be. It does require imagination to picture how the differences embedded in a historical setting actually shaped people’s lives and thought, but I do think an author ought to be able to imagine this sort of thing. The reason it’s difficult, if it is, could be that it hasn’t occurred to someone that “the past is a foreign country” at all, or that “they do things differently there.” In other words, the author may assume attitudes haven’t changed over time and everybody in whatever historical setting was really just like American post-2000, or even post 2010, or even post 2020. It’s an extreme failure to realize that although human instinct remains constant, human societies do not, and the general beliefs and mores of the people in those societies do not. However, a basic awareness of history does not seem to me to be an unreasonable expectation for an author of historical fiction.

While we’re on this subject, more or less, here’s a somewhat related Substack post: How to Write Alternative Histories & Possible Problems with the Genre

Alternative history is a captivating genre that hinges on a “point of divergence”—the moment where historical fact veers into fiction. Whether it’s a delayed invention (the printing press, invented in Luther’s own hometown, made the Reformation possible) or an imagined difference in geography, the goal is to explore the ripple effects of change that reshape societies, cultures and events.

Fairly facile post. There has to be something more thoughtful and interesting out there. Ah!

From Patricia Wrede: Alternate History

For those unfamiliar with the genre, alternate history or alternate universe (AU) fiction is where the author changes the outcome of some historical event, or introduces some new non-historical event or thing into real history, and then works out (or pretends to work out) how this change affects the background of the story. Sometimes, the author is looking at the world years, decades, or centuries after the change, as in Randall Garrett’s Lord Darcy stories, which are set in the early 1900s in a world where the point of change was that Richard the Lion-Hearted did not die from the crossbow wound, but instead recovered and reigned for a good many more years, during which somebody discovered how to make magic work reliably. So that author has roughly 900 years for that one alteration to affect the history we know.

I remembered the Lord Darcy stories involved this basic setting, but I did not recall there was a point of divergence at all, far less what it was. Significantly more thoughtful post, partly because Wrede is not trying to promulgate rules and wrap a post around the rules, but instead taking specific examples of alternate history novels — mostly Guns of the South — to discuss the idea of alternate history.

One more: Statistical Modeling, Causal Inference, and Social Science

In her book, “Telling it like it wasn’t: The counterfactual imagination in history and fiction,” Catherine Gallagher usefully distinguishes between three sorts of historical speculation:

1. Counterfactual histories which are “generally analytical rather than narrative” and “indicate multiple possibilities that went unrealized rather than to trace out single historical alternative trajectories in detail.”

2. Alternate histories, which “describe one continuous sequence of departures from the historical record, thereby inventing a long counterfactual nearrative with a correspondingly divergent fictional world, while drawing the dramatis personae exclusively form the actual historical record.”

3. Alternate-history novels, which “invent not only alternative-history trajectories but also fictional characters . . . presenting in detail the social, cultural, technological, psychological, and emotional totalities that result from the alterations.”

This is another short post, more focused on examples of real novels than “tips for how to write.”

Alternate history, and also sociological SF, and what I want to call sociological fantasy, plus some urban fantasy where there is some sort of “masquerade” that ends so that the secret history is revealed, or where the world changes and there is abruptly a point of divergence, except close to the modern day — all of that, I think, can be treated as “historical fiction” in a sense, and Emma Darwin’s points apply to all of it, to a greater or lesser degree. Some UF does not take itself at all seriously (Ilona Andrews’ Innkeeper series), but neither does some putatively straight historical fiction (Secret History of the Pink Carnation, I am looking at you). For historical fiction and for any fiction with the flavor of historical fiction, if the author wants to take the setting seriously and wants the reader to do the same, Emma Darwin’s advice looks solid. One more “thing that goes wrong” from her post:

An inconsistently historical voice. Voice in historical fiction can work as hard as Paul Kingsnorth in The Wake to channel an Anglo-Saxon narrator, or be as cheerfully modern-sounding as Robert Harris’s Romans in Pompeii. But once the reader has made their trust-fall into voices of a certain register and is happily reading narration and dialogue as if (for now) they’re real, a jolt into a different register jolts that trust.

Right, and this goes for everything adjacent to historical fiction — everything that the author actually wants the reader to buy into. In all these genres and subgenres, the author ought to understand something how societies develop, how societies shape life for individual, and how cultural assumptions and mores become so deeply embedded that people scarcely recognize them as assumptions.

Please Feel Free to Share:

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

Historical Fiction Read More »

Update: Just Under the Wire. Also, vote for a character name!

All right, so I called Vayu’s story finished on October 31st, which was not EXACTLY purposeful, but it’s funny how it worked out that way. I do have a handful of notes to myself, but I sent it to early readers …

… I should say, I sent it to Kim first, and based on her feedback made a substantial change to smooth out chronology. So that part is finished, and I don’t *think* I’m going to change my mind about how the story is structured at this point. Which is: Chapter 1 sets the scene; it’s very visual, it’s a scene in which most of the important characters are brought visually into the scene, while basically nothing happens. Except that the reader also gets a feel for Vayu, what he’s like, his situation, which is to say, he’s fundamentally tense and isolated. This scene occurs in autumn / early winter, shortly after arriving at the inKera winter camp at the foot of the northern mountains.

Then we step all the way back to immediately after Tarashana and right after Lisig’s story, during the journey to Talal Sabero — the sacred mountain, you may recall — with Tano, Raga, and Arayo. That’s chapter 2, in which we see Vayu as an active, competent person. Then the story moves forward from there, through the whole warm season, catches up to the present day in the middle of the story, and keeps moving forward.

So this structure is practically the antithesis of Lisig’s story, which is extremely simple and takes place over just a few days. The two stories are different in other ways, too. Nothing in Lisig’s story is “active” as such. It’s an intimate slice-of-life story. Vayu’s story is much more active, especially in the back half. I’ll be so interested in reader reactions to both stories, and who prefers which story to the other. I do hope and expect most readers will enjoy both stories.

Oh, and I moved both epilogues to the end, so if anybody initially thinks, Wait, where’s Lisig’s epilogue? It’s at the end, immediately before Vayu’s epilogue. I made the epilogues parallel in that both begin with a long letter. I hope you enjoy the letters, and by the way, the single best thing about the paper editions is that you can use great script fonts for handwritten letters. You can’t in the ebook because the reader, not the author, picks the font for the ebook. The best you can do is italicize the letter. There are quite wonderful fonts and they are really fun to try out — “Beautiful! But is it readable? Readable! But does it look like this character would write in this hand?”

So, winding it up with inKera, and this certainly is satisfying.

MEANWHILE

Please vote: Huzarek Huokorek Hukukol Haokaath Haokaal Haizhur

I like a couple of those, and if nobody complains bitterly that they hate those potential names in that list, then I’ll pick one and move forward. If you don’t like any of those, then feel free to suggest a different name that fits the following criteria, because that might be genuinely helpful:

Starts with an H; does not look like a Lau name, a Lakasha name, an Ugaro name, or a Tarashana name.

You’ve seen a lot of names, so you know what they look like, but you might not have specifically noticed which letters don’t occur in darau, in taksu, or in lasije.

Letters that do not occur in darau: f  j  q  x  w  z

Letters that do not occur in taksu: c   ch  f  j  q  x  z

Letters that do not occur in lasije: c   ch  f  o  q  w  x  y  z

This shows us what is have to work with when creating a new language that doesn’t look like any of the above. The Saa’arii language is called athaan (I don’t expect anybody remembers, but this was mentioned and I have it my notes). Athaan obviously should have some letters and features not seen in the other three languages. Here are the letters and letter combinations I think athaan DOES or MIGHT include: d  f h  k  m  q  qa qu r  w  z   kh th zh  hw jw  qh  zr  vz  sk  sz a  aa  ai  oa i  ii  a’a  a’ai  a’u

Common endings:  -az  -aq  -ir  -ek  -esk  -oth -al –aal -ol -ur

And, on top of everything else, it’s ideal if a word looks like it might exist in a non-English linguistic tradition and doesn’t scream FANTASY CHARACTER NAME too loudly. The Tarashana names are meant to look a bit Elven, meaning Tolkienian Elven. But in general, I do try to avoid names that look like Ye Olde Fantasie Names. I’m perfectly aware this quality is in the eye of the beholder. Nevertheless.

So, do you like any of the possible H names above? And if not, can you create an H name you like better, that fits potential patterns for athaan?

And if you surmise from the above that I have indeed picked up Hedesa II now that it’s November and I’m about finished with inKera, you’re right. I’m going to quit calling it Hedesa II as soon as I have an H name that will work for a Saa’arii character.

Please Feel Free to Share:

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

Update: Just Under the Wire. Also, vote for a character name! Read More »

Scroll to Top