A post from Emma Darwin: Why You Should Learn To Wrangle Long Sentences As Well As Short Ones: And why they’re not as difficult to handle as you’d think
This struck me as funny because … I mean … long sentences are fun! And not difficult to handle! But mostly, fun.
61. “And so we stood together like that, at the top of that field for what seemed like ages, not saying anything, just holding each other, while the wind kept blowing and blowing at us, tugging our clothes, and for a moment, it seemed like we were holding onto each other because that was the only way to stop us from being swept away into the night.”
— Kazuo Ishiguro
This is #61 in a list of 100 beautiful sentences. What do you think? Beautiful? I like it. It’s a simple sentence to read. There’s nothing tricky about it. Oh, here’s one:
69. “They were sorry, they were saying with their bodies, they were accepting each other back, and that feeling, that feeling of being accepted back again and again, of someone’s affection for you always expanding to encompass whatever new flawed thing had just manifested in you, that was the deepest, dearest thing he’d ever—”
– George Saunders
I noticed this one because I really liked A Swim in a Pond in the Rain. Even though Saunders did not persuade me to rush out and read a lot of short stories by Russian authors. Even so, I certainly now notice his name.
Here’s one of the longest sentences at the “beautiful sentences” post:
16. “On the ground, in the cave, now wrapped in darkness, they found themselves airborne over hills and valleys, floating through blue clouds to the mountaintop of pure ecstasy, from where, suspended in space, they felt the world go round and round, before they descended, sliding down a rainbow, toward the earth, their earth, where the grass, plants, and animals seemed to be singing a lullaby of silence as Nyawira and Kamiti, now locked in each other’s arms, slept the sleep of babies, the dawn of a new day awaiting.”
– Ngugi Wa Thiong’o
Well, here is Emma Darwin’s intro to her post:
The prevailing orthodoxy among many of my fellow writers – not to mention writing teachers and students – is that short sentences, specially with the simple syntax which they’re also likely to have, are ‘punchier’. They’re striking. Listen! They seem urgent and forceful. They demand to be heard. Readers notice them. Long sentences, on the other hand, go slowly, take too long, bog readers down, bore them – and we don’t want to be doing that, do we?
And I do wonder. Surely no one is saying that every! single! sentence! should be short and punchy, because … I mean … how would that work? A sentence can only be punchy in contrast with the surrounding sentences. If every sentence is one to five words long, or one to seven words long, then none of them can feel punchy; instead, the whole lot of them together will sound choppy. That’s a great paragraph, though. I really like how Emma uses a set of five short sentences and then slooooows down with a longer sentence. I just wonder if she is exaggerating the prevailing orthodoxy. And where is Emma going with this?
Ah, she is arguing that each sentence must move forward; or rather, that each sentence must cause the reader to move forward. And short sentences stop. They keep stopping. Every period is a stop. And therefore the reader must keep going forward without as much help from the sentence itself; the reader has to keep making a jump past each period. THIS IS JUST LIKE SAYING THAT SHORT SENTENCES DO NOT PRODUCE A FAST FEEL, which is great, because I’ve noticed that too! Writing advice often tells you that short sentences speed up the action, but this isn’t true! Or, at least, usually it isn’t true. And the reason is: each period is a full stop, and stopping over and over slows the action down.
Emma then provides different ways of building long sentences: with lots of conjunctions, for example. Why, yes, conjunctions are used to link clauses and lead the reader forward. That’s what they’re for. Then a sentence with prepositional phrases and causal clauses. Then sentences with parenthetical clauses. In every case, the sentences are easy to parse …
… or they are if readers have any experience whatsoever reading prose. I wonder if reading prose is still something we see in schools at all, or mostly something we now see mostly in homes. I mean, homes where parents read and have books around. However, some long sentences are just intrinsically easy to parse because the author signposts all the way through them. Another post here: All long sentences must eventually end.
Anyway, Emma Darwin ends with some examples of long sentences, such as this one:
‘Halt! In the name of the City!’ cried a voice, and then came a watchman’s rattle and a clatter of arms. Gil dropped the tar-pot and everything else and ran, his hand ready to pull his knife as it might be in a forest of wolves, and ran and ran and ran, over walls and under towers, through bramble-patches and burnt-out buildings, pelting along alleys, dodging into the shadows at the sound of the Watch, running again when it had passed, until as the night thinned and paled his fear was overtaken by exhaustion and he fetched up where a bridge led over a small canal, doubled-over with his chest heaving. [91 words]
And you see at once how the author provides signposts for the reader all the way through, of course.
‘Halt! In the name of the City!’ cried a voice, and then came a watchman’s rattle and a clatter of arms. Gil dropped the tar-pot and everything else and ran, his hand ready to pull his knife as it might be in a forest of wolves, and ran and ran and ran, over walls and under towers, through bramble-patches and burnt-out buildings, pelting along alleys, dodging into the shadows at the sound of the Watch, running again when it had passed, until as the night thinned and paled his fear was overtaken by exhaustion and he fetched up where a bridge led over a small canal, doubled-over with his chest heaving.
You could correctly add several more commas: to set off “as the night thinned and paled” as a parenthetical clause and also after “doubled over.” However, I think it’s a good idea to thin the herd of optional commas in a sentence this long. It’s a fine sentence, quite easy to read because the author leads the reader through it.
Oh, here’s a fun exercise:
One of John Gardner’s exercises in The Art of Fiction is to write three effective long sentences: each at least one full typed page (250 words), each involving a different emotion (for example, anger, pensiveness, sorrow, joy). Purpose: control of tone in a complex sentence.
I love it. Not the “evoking emotion” part; I don’t care about that. The long sentence part sounds delightful. I’ve thought for years that if I were taking an English Comp I class again, I would entertain myself by writing an essay where each paragraph consisted of a single perfectly correct sentence. I wonder if an instructor would notice? Because if you did it smoothly enough, maybe not, and that would be especially entertaining.
Great footnote on the linked post:
I sometimes wonder if some of the teacher-level orthodoxy is because some beginner writers have so little sense of how to construct a long sentence that works. It’s easier just to tell them to keep it short. But as anyone who’s been hanging round the Itch for a while knows, I don’t believe that the fact that’s something’s hard to do well means we shouldn’t do it, teach it, and flourish the results in the face of the rule-bound.
I’m certain that heaps of bad writing orthodoxy arises from this exact source. “Don’t use passive voice” emerges from “Because you can’t do it right and it’s painful for me to read your writing when you do it badly, so just don’t do it.” Same with “Don’t use semicolons” — which I have encountered teachers who forbade students to use semicolons, so I’m not making this up. Again, “Because you can’t do it right and it’s too much trouble to teach you how to use semicolons, so don’t use them.” I hate it. Even though I realize many students are terribly unskilled; I’m not arguing that point. I just don’t think the way to teach skill is to forbid students to use legitimate and useful elements of the language.
Thanks for reminding me of Ngugi wa Thiongo. I can still remember in the fog of the season’s end. Time for a reread.