Villain points of View

From Mythcreants: When to Narrate a Villain’s Point of View

Subtitle of the post: Using a villain’s point of view can do more harm than good.

My response: No kidding, in two major ways, both of which ought to be obvious, so authors should think about this before choosing to show the villain’s point of view:

1) Many readers detest villain pov scenes and, in increasing order of not-great for the author, either skim them, skip them, or toss the book on the not-for-me pile.

2) Including the villain pov can drop the tension into the basement, not in a good way.

The first problem is complicated, because this group includes readers who don’t like switching pov period, and therefore switching to the villain’s pov irritates them because of the switch. But it also includes the readers who just really do not like being forced into the villain’s pov, even if they are okay with multiple pov as a general rule. I’m in both categories personally, the second category (much) more strongly than the first. However, on top of the problem of turning off roughly half your readers by including villain pov sections at all, the author also risks turning off the other half of the readers because they just don’t like THIS villain.

Letting one character carry the pov is simple. Readers who like the character and like the style and story will find this a smooth reading experience, because why not? But, every time you hand the pov to an additional character, you guarantee that some readers will like one pov character more than the other, that the reader will have one favorite pov character out of the bunch, and that some readers will therefore feel impatient with / bored by at least one pov character. I don’t think this is avoidable because, spoiler, readers are individuals and idiosyncratic and always have specific reactions to the various characters in a novel. This is fine, but an author who includes villain pov chapters therefore risks turning off all the readers who hate villain pov chapters, all the readers who hate THIS villain, all the readers who just dislike switching pov, AND on top of that, the author risks hitting #2, a severe and absolutely unnecessary drop in tension.

And the best example of this I can think of is The Invisible Ring by Anne Bishop, which also suffered from Idiotic Protagonist Syndrome, so the book wound up being interesting for me as an example of Things That Do Not Work.

And in this case, including the villain point of view chapters meant not only was the reader dragged into the gutter with the villain, but also the villain’s nefarious plans were revealed ahead of time, just to make SURE the reader would not be startled by plot twists. Offhand, it does not seem like a great idea for the author to spoil all the plot twists, but that is basically the situation in this book. And that’s what I think the Mythcreant’s post is going to point at. Let’s take a look …

Here’s the relevant section of their post:

Loss of Threat

Even though the most common reason for using a villain point of view is to raise the tension in the story, these viewpoints often do the opposite.

  • The elements in the scene that are designed to raise tension often fall flat. Vague plans and evil laughter often don’t feel real enough to make readers care. If the villain simply threatens the hero’s life, readers will know the attempt is doomed to failure or the story couldn’t continue.
  • Once readers not only meet the villain, but also get inside their head, the villain won’t be scary. Instead, they’re more likely to be sympathetic. Some villains are sympathetic and still threatening enough to carry the story, but the villain has to be designed and depicted just right.
  • If the villain is doing anything that doesn’t make sense, it will make them feel incompetent. Then most of the tension that villain could have created will be lost.
Sloppy Narration

When you write from a character’s point of view, readers will expect you to convey whatever that character knows. When the point-of-view character is a villain, that becomes an issue. If the readers find out everything the villain is planning, there won’t be enough surprises left in the story.

***

That last bit is what I had in mind. Obviously villain stupidity might also be an issue. Characters who are really caricatures of evil also aren’t great. But I was thinking of the author shoving the reader into position to see all the nefarious plans, and therefore spoiling everything. When the good guys know the bad guys are out there planning something, why tell the reader what’s coming? I can think of ways to make that work, but fundamentally, why try to make it work? Just let the readers be surprised along with the good guys!

***

As a separate issue, the thing about making the villain sympathetic is not a concern for me. If the villain is actually a bad guy, I’m unlikely to go along with excuses. “I had an unhappy childhood, so now I torture kittens” is not going to work for me. I can think of exactly one actual villain with whom I am sort of sympathetic: Macael in Sherwood Smith’s Let the Torrent Dance Thee Down, which is set post-Norsunder War.

The war is over, all but the cleanup. And the emotional recovery, with its scars both visible and invisible. Liere Fer Eider learns on the run how to become a queen, while Andri adjusts to life this side of the law. Senrid, in devastated Marloven Hess, has to straight-arm a rage-filled populace into peace. While on a faraway mountain Detlev at last oversees the rebuilding of his school for training re-emerging psychic powers after four millennia. … A few years pass, and everything seems to be settling into the new norm–until Liere wakes from a drugged sleep to an enemy who offers an impossible choice.

It’s the drugged sleep and the enemy. This is the guy I’m thinking of. He is just … really interesting. Very competent in so many ways, but he does not quite grasp how normal people work, emotionally. Plus, eggs, omelets, it’s a thing. We never see his pov, I should add. We see this character only from the outside, and (as usual) I think that works better. (A lot better.) Sherwood Smith makes Macael both interesting and sympathetic without bringing the reader into his head, which, incidentally, demonstrates that we don’t need to be inside the pov of a character to find him sympathetic.

We see Macael again at a distance in Sherwood’s upcoming release, Spark Royal, which I really liked a lot, by the way.

This is one of hers that’s focused. Two pov characters (neither a villain). Main protagonist: David, one of Detlev’s boys, now a calm, competent, responsible adult. Second protagonist, Ris, the female lead in this low-angst romance. Simple plot that does not sprawl in all possible directions. High competence, low tension. Coming out in October, I see. I do recommend it. Macael, as I say, is seen at a distance here, and he is incredibly interesting and almost … allllmost … sympathetic. Except all those broken eggs! I would like to see him in a careful, thorough redemption arc, which is, I think actually the plan.

***

The Mythcreants add:

Before you consider whether you need to include a villain’s point of view, take a critical look at your plot and your protagonist. … If your protagonist isn’t involved in the big conflicts of the story, it can be tempting to use another point of view to foreshadow the threat and show off the action. But in most of these cases, a better solution is to change your plot so the protagonist is more central to the action.

That certainly seems reasonable!

Whereas a big bad usually needs to be super threatening, a minion or side villain is free to be sympathetic instead. You can use character thoughts to build a little rapport between the minion and your readers. Just keep in mind that if you use the same character repeatedly or focus on their personal journey heavily, readers will expect the character to be important later. However, that’s as much an opportunity as it is a restriction. Give the minion a redemption arc that allows them to contribute to Team Good during the climax.

I’m in favor of practically anything that will result in a good redemption story, so although I would not generally suggest multiplying points of view so far you include minions, I nevertheless like this idea. Actually, I can think of one book that is an example of this — not a subplot included in the main series, but a subplot lifted out into its own book later: Iron and Magic by Ilona Andrews.

Hugh d’Ambray, Preceptor of the Iron Dogs, Warlord of the Builder of Towers, served only one man. Now his immortal, nearly omnipotent master has cast him aside. Hugh is a shadow of the warrior he was, but when he learns that the Iron Dogs, soldiers who would follow him anywhere, are being hunted down and murdered, he must make a choice: to fade away or to be the leader he was born to be. Hugh knows he must carve a new place for himself and his people, but they have no money, no shelter, and no food, and the necromancers are coming. Fast.

Hugh was a minion of the dark lord, and now here he is, and the reader finds out that he was essentially mind-controlled to not realize how terrible his immomrtal, nearly omnipotent master actually was. He turns out to be sympathetic, so this is a great example, even though this is not an extra pov in the main series.

***

So, villain points of view: not something to throw in lightly because you just feel like you need to explain the nefarious plan to the reader in order to build tension. No, probably notice that this does not build tension, and also, ugh, villain points of view.

I guess I’d better add the standard disclaimer:

Antagonists are not the same thing as villains.

Antagonists can easily be much more sympathetic than villains, and are not nearly as big a turn-off for me personally, or for anyone else who does not want to be dragged into the pov of someone who tortures kittens, but is fine being invited into the pov of someone who is not allied with the protagonist. One of my favorite set-ups is: Two characters, unavoidably opposed, each wants something for good reasons, they can’t both win, go! And my preferred resolution is: They can both win, in this interesting twist that was set up properly, so it’s a surprise, but a justified surprise.

One good example: MWT’s Queen’s Thief series, where Eugenides and Attolia are antagonists for quite some time, but obviously don’t wind up as enemies.

Another is Spinning Silver, which is just a wonderful story.

Shards of Honor might fit as well.

Anybody else got a suggestion for a story with this kind of structure?

Please Feel Free to Share:

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

6 thoughts on “Villain points of View”

  1. I thought immediately of the anime Code Geass. Two characters, one advocates reform from within, the other revolution. They clash.
    The Teen suggests Vespertine for the title character and Leander.
    The manga Pandora Hearts, ( I looked puzzled): The whole plot -it’s a corkscrew.
    And adds There’s a very well done villain/enemy pov in the fanfic Shadow Unending. It really is a villain pov, but it works quite well, i thought. In that we may know what motivates him, and what he’s after, but his narrative only provides context to things our other five narrators observe. I’m quite impressed with the author for pulling it off. Each narrator only sees pieces of the puzzle, and no one gets it all.
    There are precisely two chapters that break pattern, and one of them might’ve been unneeded. the other one was as far as I can tell, the only way to make a later thread not come completely out of nowhere. Some things that had been planted at various points might’ve been enough to say something about that thread, but not enough for the action of the inscrutable party opposing the villain to make perfect sense without that inscrutable party’s involvement with the unexpected narrator. And that unexpected narrator was the inscrutable party’s ace in the hole for one of the major endgame movements.
    I have no idea how readable The Shadow Unending is to someone who is not into The Elder Scrolls franchise and lore. It does makes sense to me (Teen) even without having read the trilogy it’s a sequel to. And it’s a story in a very specific world, at a specific time and place. For context, the setting is one where the twelve constellations each rules one of the twelve months, and the thirteenth constellation (The Serpent) moves through the night menacing the other twelve.
    Of of the twelve constellations is The Shadow.
    And a major element to the story is that the month of Shadow (Second Seed) isn’t ending. The Shadow hasn’t left the sky. Even the Serpent isn’t moving.
    Major arcane things have happened. This isn’t about them. it’s about the aftermath.

  2. I’ve used it. I even opened Even After with it, though I cut to the heroine very quickly.
    But then, the villains’ increasing awareness of what a menace she was meant that the danger could increase even if a villain was picked off.

  3. On villain POVs being necessary for readers to understand them… I have noticed among Tolkien fandom a great many people find the Silmarillion (& HoME) characters of Feanor and his sons very interesting and relatable (I guess). We never get a look into their heads in what writings JRRT left of them. in fact I ran across an analysis not long ago of how he treated Feanor through his writing lifetime: Every time he changed something, he made the character more villainous, same with his sons. Yet lots of people appreciate them and not because they’re villains. It’s interesting to observe.

  4. Re: antagonists – Ayt Mada in the Green Bone Saga by Fonda Lee is probably the best antagonist I’ve read in recent years. The story is about rival clans and she’s the leader of one clan. She’s definitely an antagonist rather than a villain, as both clans are kinda equal in terms of (a)morality (it’s not that they are amoral, exactly, more that they operate according to their own code). They both have their reasons for what they do and the stances they take, and you could imagine that a different story where Ayt Mada is the protagonist and No Peak (the other clan) is the antagonist.

    Also, love the shout-out for Iron and Magic! That book kinda flabbergasted me, as a masterly demonstration of “how you turn a villain into a protagonist” – I didn’t know that was possible. When I finished I kinda had to pick my jaw up off the floor, at what the authors had acccomplished.

    (Disclaimer: I read a lot, but not outside certain parameters, if that makes sense, so it’s entirely possible that I’ve missed many books that do the above things very well also…)

  5. I was also pretty astonished that they pulled off that redemption arc. It’s a heck of an arc. I’d like them to go on with that series!

  6. I don’t like spending time in the heads of genuine villains. I notice this particularly in the In Death series, where most of the books have little or no villain time, but a few have quite a. And just, no.

    You get a different perspective on a villain from another book in K J Charles’s The Henchmen of Zenda. I have loved The Prisoner of Zenda for decades and I still enjoyed the way Henchmen took the incidents from the original book, inserted a half twist, and swapped most of the heroes and villains.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top