Otiose and Friends

Okay, so I bumped into the word “otiose” the other day, which was defined in that context as “without useful effect” or “without noticeable effect.” This was interesting because I sort of thought of it as meaning the same thing as “superfluous” …

Merriam Webster says:

Otiose adjective oti·​ose  ˈō-shē-ˌōs  

1: producing no useful result : futile

2: being at leisure : idle

3: lacking use or effect : functionless

*********

Superfluous adjective su·​per·​flu·​ous  su̇-ˈpər-flü-əs 

1a: exceeding what is sufficient or necessary : extra

1b: not needed : unnecessary

*********

So, first, the words are plainly different! Did you all know what “otiose” means? And, second question, have you ever actually used it, as far as you know? I hereby admit that I must not have ever felt all that comfortable about understanding what it meant, because I’m almost sure I’ve never used it. I think if I’d been clear about the meaning, I would have, because I like interesting and unusual words.

This also made me immediately think of a different word from the same basic family, as it does — I mean, doesn’t drawing fine lines between and around words make you want to think of related words?

Supererogatory adjective su·​per·​erog·​a·​to·​ry sü-pər-i-ˈrä-gə-ˌtȯr-ē 

1: observed or performed to an extent not enjoined or required

*********

I don’t really like that definition. Let me try again. Here’s Dictionary.com:

Supererogatory American Adjective   soo-per-uh–rog–uh-tawr-ee, -tohr-ee ˌsu pər əˈrɒg əˌtɔr i, -ˌtoʊr i

  1. going beyond the requirements of duty.
  2. greater than that required or needed.

*********

Are they trying to indicate that “supererogatory” is used in America, or is more common in America, or was coined in America? Jack Vance was American and he’s the author who taught me this word, which I read as #2, so I am rather keen on seeing that #1 is apparently the more common (“common”) meaning. Google tells me that saying the word is “American” means “in more common use in America.” Maybe, but I don’t think I’ve ever seen anybody use it except Jack Vance, so “more commonly used” means “seldom if ever used by normal people in normal conversation.”

I appreciate Dictionary.com giving me the pronunciation phonetically as well as in (unreadable to me) linguistics letters. Here’s another word that’s related but distinct:

*********

Gratuitous American Adjective   gruh–too-i-tuhs grəˈtu ɪ təs, -ˈtju-

  1. being without apparent reason, cause, or justification. It looks to me like a baseless and gratuitous insult—like you have a huge chip on your shoulder.
  2. given, done, bestowed, or obtained without charge or payment; free; complimentary.
  3. Law. given without receiving any return value.

*********

And of course the word “gratuitous” has drifted quite a bit, hasn’t it? I think it’s used almost exclusively in combination with negative things: “gratuitous violence,” “a gratuitous insult.” You might say something like, “He offered me gratuitous advice,” and you would be indicating you felt his advice was not just unnecessary, but annoying. I’m not sure I’ve ever seen “gratuitous” used to mean “unnecessary but excellent,” so I wonder if the second meaning has largely disappeared. Or I just might not have noticed “gratuitous” being used that way. Of course I see that “gratuity” is from the same word and that’s where it connects to the second meaning.

*********

Here’s one more word you may like because it is especially obscure. Dictionary dot com falls down on this one; I got the definition from Wiktionary.

Supervacaneous Adjective  so͞o’pərvəkāʹnĭəs  syo͞o’pərvəkāʹnĭəs  suːpəvəˈkeɪnɪəs  ˌsjuːpəvəˈkeɪnɪəs

1:  Added above what is needed or necessary; superfluous, redundant. 

    *********

    And at this point perhaps one might reasonably decide that the word “supervacaneous” might be rather superfluous. However, I think we all enjoy the huge English vocabulary, where heaps of related words are not quite synonyms. I’m going to take a stab at using “otiose” in casual conversation a few times this month. Also “supererogatory,” because while Jack Vance was never a favorite author of mine, I can’t think of many other authors who have seemed to have as much fun with great words as he did.

    Please Feel Free to Share:

    Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

    9 thoughts on “Otiose and Friends”

    1. I’m not sure if you read Scott Alexander’s blog, but I’ve seen him use ‘supererogatory’ to mean doing something good beyond what is morally required. For example that donating money to charity is supererogatory.

    2. I had never seen supervacaneous, and it seems a bit superfluous as a word.
      Otiose I have seen and understood in context, though I couldn’t have come up with a definition withous seeing it in context. The rest I knew.
      I do like all the subtle distinctions between these splendid words and all the possibilities in the astoundingly wide-ranging English vocabulary.

    3. I have seen otiose used but seeing without any context I tend to default to thinking it has something to do with obesity.

      Supererogatory seems to come from theology and philosophy, which is where I’ve seen it used. Why label the term American I have no idea.

      Never seen that last one supervacaneous.

    4. I’ve heard of superfluous and gratuitous…

      It is funny how words and phrases drift over time. I’ve always been amused at how “blown away” has come to be a positive statement as opposed to a method of execution!

    5. Gratuitous:
      2. given, done, bestowed, or obtained without charge or payment; free; complimentary.

      Reminded me of lagniappe, which has always delighted me.

      Sometimes a flourish is gratuitous, which while not entirely positive, at least allows whimsey.

      For a while, Jack Vance was among my favorite authors – I had to read through the 70’s to get to the 80’s, 90’s and beyond.

    6. I read Alexander’s blog all the time when he focused more on psychiatry and less on AI. These days, I just look in occasionally. I would remember if I’d seen him use the word “supererogatory!” It’s such a fabulous word, and thoroughly connected to Jack Vance, so I would notice it. I ought to specifically try using all these words in casual conversation. Except “supervacaneous,” which does seem rather superfluous …

    7. Great sentence, Susan! “Sometimes a flourish is gratuitous, which while not entirely positive, at least allows whimsey.” –> And also, true!

    8. Several of these are new to me and I ran into the weeds on trying to guess their meaning. I wanted to make otiose relate to the ears, as in otic. And I was trying to make supererogatory the opposite of derogatory, which it is not.

      Words with subtle distinctions are fun. In my professional writing I tended to avoid them because they could impede comprehension if the reader didn’t get the distinction and was unlikely to look it up. I was usually writing things where the language should be transparent so the meaning could come through. But in the kind of essay where your audience likes words, where stopping to enjoy a well-crafted sentence or a precise word is a feature and not a bug, it’s great stuff.

    Leave a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Scroll to Top