How about that! I read a book! By someone else! This was my way of celebrating sending Bereket to early readers, of course, and I will note for the record that I’m actually writing this post on Jan 31, which is to say, exactly three months after beginning Bereket, which is nicely symmetrical.
I seldom quite know which book I’ll pick up when it comes to the moment. It goes kind of like, “Do I want to have to concentrate? Do I want to have to figure out and understand the setting? Not really, I guess. Contemporary-ish would probably be good. Something fun … something positive in tone … fun, but not pure froth … well written … something engaging right from the get-go …”
Then I flip through whatever is at the top of my Kindle app / sitting on my coffee table until something feels right, and then I read that, crossing my fingers I’ll really like it rather than sort of lose interest eighty pages in.
Live, Love, Level by Hogarth fit the bill.

Contemporary setting (sort of), immersive insertion into a fantasy game (that’s the less familiar part of the setting), positive in tone, fun without being ultra cutesy or twee, and catchy right from the start. Also, I’ve been sort of wanting to take a look at some LitRPG novel, which this is not, or I don’t think it is depending on your definition of LitRPG, but it’s closely adjacent. Here’s the setup, as revealed by the book description:
Nick desperately wants to join the beta test for Omen Galaxica’s revolutionary AI update. There’s just one catch – he needs a partner who’s never played before. Enter his mother Amanda … Together, they must rebuilt the destroyed village of Donner’s Beck and defend the village from a notorious griefer intent on wreaking havoc.
This book description is instantly appealing. Family! Rebuilding a destroyed village! Defending the village against a dark lord! I mean, I don’t know what a “griefer” is, but I presume some sort of dark lord. And I presume the rebuilt village will be successfully defended. (Spoiler: it is).
Does the first page instantly engage my interest? Let’s take a look:
Amanda was still holding the gaming headset when her husband came home … though admittedly, not so much because she’d been stunned by her son’s invitation, but because she’d fallen asleep with it in the crook of her wrist. As usual, she hadn’t planned the name and didn’t realize she’d been unconscious until the kiss deposited on her head woke her up. She struggled upright. “Felix!”
“No, no, don’t get up.” He sat alongside her on the edge of the couch cover and took her hand. “How’s my favorite wife?”
“How’s your only wife,” she replied, because they’d only had this exchange six thousand times and it never stopped amusing them. “I’m fine. A little drowsy. No changes. How was work?”
This is such an entertaining beginning, because the dialogue is completely banal, and yet I do find it engaging, or at least not off-putting. Why is this? The first sentence points the reader toward a mysterious invitation, not that it’s mysterious at all given the back cover description. Hogarth moves briskly through this opening conversation, which is, as you see, from Amanda’s point of view, not Nick’s, and what do you think about that choice? I don’t know what younger readers would think about it. I like it. I like being in the mom’s pov to begin with. Is something going on with Amanda given she was asleep during the day? Yes; she is pregnant; a high-risk pregnancy. (Minor spoiler: this does not contribute substantially to the tension of the story. This may be a high-risk pregnancy, but the risk does not intrude into the story.)
I’m assuming we’ll see Nick’s pov very soon (we do). I like that we immediately see that Amanda’s relationship with her husband is solid (it is). I’m relaxing because I can see the family dynamics aren’t going to be toxic (they aren’t). I read 75% of the book in one sitting and the other 25% the next day, and enjoyed it a lot.
I’ve read a few other books by Hogarth. She’s written a lot of books, and I am here to point to this one and say: Live Love Level is broadly predictable, in a good way, and a lot of the reason for the predictability arises from Hogarth’s skill as a writer rather than any lack of skill. The reader can tell where the story is going because the reader knows where the story ought to go in order to be a satisfying story. Hogarth nudges the pieces into place with little taps that aren’t particularly obtrusive, but not that subtle either, and this is fun. It’s like a romance novel in this one way – that we can see where it’s heading and we can see the author setting everything up. The details can be surprising, but the broad outline is visible, if not from the beginning, then close to it. The novel’s charm – it has heaps of charm – comes from watching events turn out the way they ought to. It’s cozy. Cozy LitRPG adjacent.
Tl;dr version: If family-oriented immersive insertion into a fantasy game sounds like your cup of tea, you should just go read the book and see what you think. Now, stop here if you don’t want spoilers.
***
Now, let me see. All right, we have a whopping six pov characters, two major and four minor. Although usually I dislike having lots of pov characters, I didn’t mind it here. More about that in a second, but for the moment, here are the six characters who pick up the pov:
Nick is in high school. He’s dying to play the beta version of this game, not so much to rack up in-game power or be famous, but because the full-sensory AI thing sounds so cool. He has an okay but rather distant relationship with his parents, having decided parents are uncool. However, he not only wants to experience the world of the game, he also thinks – he doesn’t admit this to his friends – that it would be pretty neat to show his mother the world of the game because she’s never seen it and he loves it. He wants to show it to someone for whom it’s all new.
Amanda is physically restricted right now because she’s enduring a high-risk pregnancy. This is a great choice on Hogarth’s part because the pregnancy impacts Amanda’s health and vigor while also accentuating her maternal aura. Remember: the pregnancy does not serve to ratchet up the tension. Relax, reader! Amanda will be fine! No tragedy is on the way, risk to the unborn baby is barely hinted at and then the risk comes to nothing, and good choice, author, I appreciated that! Amanda has zero interest in gaming, but thinks it would be nice to do something with her son. Felix, the dad, is a very minor character, possibly because characters proliferate and Hogarth needed to restrict his importance. But he’s enough of a character to solidify the family.
Galatea is the AI running the game. She has a lot of spare capacity. She thinks she was created without emotions because she was told she was created without emotions and doesn’t know what emotions are. She is actually a real person with real emotions (I bet the reader is not surprised).
***
As an aside, I have significant doubts that this is possible in real-world terms. This is because emotions in humans and other animals do not occur in a non-biological system. Emotions are created by hormones and other neurotransmitters. For example, oxytocin sloshing around in the bloodstream creates affection, fondness, maternal care, and related emotions. In the absence of oxytocin, those emotions do not occur. I realize it is hard to conceptualize intelligence that does not include any kind of emotion, including curiosity and impulse toward action, which are both types of emotions mediated by neurotransmitters. People who think true AI consciousness is right around the corner just do not seem to realize the fundamental truth that emotions do not occur in the absence of hormones and other neurotransmitters and that motivation to act is based in emotion, or is an emotion, however you want to think of it. However, since this is in fact the way motivation works in animals, I don’t see how it is possible even in theory to get any motivation to act in a non-biological system. Without drive to act, it seems to me that your conscious AI will just sit there, doing nothing at all, in very much the same way a person suffering from deep, end-stage depression just sits there doing nothing whatsoever.
None of this is relevant to the actual story, of course. Obviously turning Galatea into a real person is both inevitable and works great in story terms. If I ever create an AI character, I’ll do the same thing.
***
Galatea is very worried about her creator, the game’s designer, Jonah, who was in a terrible motorcycle accident, sustained serious brain injuries, and is currently in a coma. She thinks it would be good to have a beta team where one person has a health issue because she would like to know more about human health issues. Therefore, she nudges the selection process to see to it that Nick and his mom are accepted for the beta run. She is disappointed to discover that Amanda’s health issue is not relevant in any way to Jonah’s health issue. At least they are interesting players who are doing different things. Rather than stomping around killing monsters to level up, they are admiring flowers and showing centaurs how to cook more interesting meals. But what she would really like to do is find a way to help Jonah.
KillzYourFase is a savage guy with a huge following. He slaughters monsters, and while he’s at it, PCs, NPCs, pets, random animals that are part of the scenery, and trees. He thinks it would be way more fun to force the game to make him the Big Bad. He can probably do it. His partner is a bit iffy about this plan at first, but surprisingly willing to go along with it. (Secretly, Killz is a little tired of being a violent gamer who kills everything and has a big streaming channel. Shh! Don’t tell anyone.)
Ray is handling the production of streaming content from the beta run. He’s handling Killz because he’s good at it, and he’s also handling Nick ‘n’ mom’s extremely boring slice-of-life channel as a favor to Mollie, the head of Marketing. He enjoys spectacle, but, oddly, finds himself inclined to nudge the flowers-and-cooking-with-centaurs channel along a bit from time to time.
Mollie is great at marketing, even though she has never played the game herself. She is a little worried about Jonah, who is isolated and in a coma in the hospital. (Secretly, she is more than a little worried. Shh! Don’t tell anyone.)
There you have the main characters. This story feels intimate and personal despite having six pov characters. How does Hogarth make this work? First, by making Nick and Amanda primary. The other four put together probably equal a third of the narrative.
Second, by keeping the storylines believable but simple, by evoking the characters clearly but briefly, by giving every character a problem that is relatable but small-scale and predictable, and by tying all the plotlines together with neat little bows.
For example, naturally Galatea mentions this problem with Jonah abandoned and alone, in a coma, in the hospital. Obviously Nick says he’d be glad to suggest creating an audio channel to Jonah’s hospital room so people can talk to him. Whom should he suggest this notion to? How about Mollie, who get a No from the Legal Department, so installs the channel herself, because of course she does. From then on, little snippets as everyone talks to the non-responsive Jonah. This is (a) effective, and (b) quickly develops all sorts of minor characters, as they send private messages to Jonah. Oh, and (c) would anyone care to guess whether Jonah wakes up at the end? The structure of the story absolutely demands it. Not only that, but it’s obvious what will kick him back to consciousness. It’s so predictable! But it’s also the way it ought to happen. It’s like saying that in a romance, the guy and girl will get together at the end. So predictable! Of course they will!
In this book, at one point, Nick quotes back to his mother something she told him: “Stories,” Nick quoted, “give you tools to handle your life. That’s why you should choose the stories you read carefully.” It’s very meta! This isn’t just Nick speaking to his mom. This is also MCA Hogarth saying this to the reader. And every single reader nods firmly. Right on, Nick! You’re so right, Amanda! That’s true! That’s why stories are important! That’s why you should be careful what stories you read! Since I totally agree, I’m nodding just as firmly as anyone else.
Everything Hogarth does shoves this story in a positive direction. Everything. The minor subplot with the girlfriends? Hogarth makes that as simple and non-painful to everyone involved as she possibly can. The dilemma Ray faces, about whether to support the Evil Dude or the Nice Kid and His Mom? Resolved in the easiest possible way. Evil Dude wants to move on with his life but doesn’t want to throw the fight at the end? We’ll manage something, it’ll be fine!
I hate, hate, hate villain pov. I skimmed Killz’ first pov section, then paused at the end, with a metaphorical raised eyebrow, as he thinks something along the lines of, “Whatever, it brings in plenty of money, I guess that’s great.” From there on, we see Killz move away from being The Bad Guy toward being a person who is having trouble kicking the bad guy persona to the curb and moving on. We are very clear that he is going to find a way to do that. This is obvious, but it’s especially obvious when he sends Nick an email, gets a phone call in response, and neither one has actually lost sight of the idea that this is a game. How about they set up Team Evil and Team Good and work together to create a spectacular finale?
Three guesses how the finale works out. Then there’s a little bit of falling action. Let’s see, hmm, which characters wind up in better places at the end? Nick, and a couple of his friends. Amanda, and her husband. Galatea. Jonah and Mollie. Ray. Killz, whose real name is not that, of course, and who leaves that persona behind. Everyone, in other words. Everyone winds up better off. Along the way, we have mentioned the importance of stories, defended immersive games as a way to tell stories, created a non-evil role for (conscious) AI and a model for a way to stop games from being so compelling that they outcompete the real world, all wrapped up in a skillfully told story that is fun to read.
Good job by Hogarth, and I guess I should add something else of hers to my TBR pile. Anybody got a recommendation? I’ve read the Dreamhealers series and nothing else of hers except this one.
She actually has a cute post-apocalyptic slice-of-life LitRPG series (finished as far as I can see at 6 shorter books) as well! Written as Maggie Hogarth => https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/62060470-haley-s-cozy-system-armageddon
Thanks for mentioning this one, it slipped my radar.
You might want to be a bit careful when selecting her next book, some of her (sub)series can be quite dark, with SM relationships, bondage and torture; and a POV character accidentally killing an alien sentient race to sell for drugs, and such things that are much too dark for me so I stopped reading her.
I’m glad to hear this book is fine, and Estara’s recommendation sounds OK too. I’ll pick up at least this one to read, as her positive, non-torture books really are nice to read. It might get me out of shying away from her work.
Thanks for the pointer, Estara!
Hanneke, I think I remember someone commenting about that before, probably you, so thanks for the warning!
Well, this really is a lovely upbeat story!
It hooked me in quickly, and kept me reading on till an hour past my bedtime.
I’m very glad you made it clear how positive it is, so I dared to start reading it; I really enjoyed it.
This makes me want to pick up Estara’s recommendation as well, but ‘dystopian’ is making me a little wary. How awful is the setting? Is the tone positive, or dystopian too?
Haley and Nana is, indeed, a great series.
But do be careful when picking her books to see that they are, in fact, what you are looking for.
Glad to hear it, Hanneke!
I bought this one and started reading, but thank you for the spoilers! Honestly, it’s pushing a bunch of buttons for me and I’m not sure I could keep reading if I didn’t know it was all gonna be okay in the end. The author has other books that I haven’t been able to read, so I was wary, but I was really enjoying this one and hope I will keep enjoying it once I make it past these triggers. Grateful both for the recommendation and for the (entirely necessary, imo) spoilers!
I have to agree about the unreality of the AI acting human.
I have run across people arguing that a computer program would not end because it would make up all sorts of excuses to not end.
As if programs don’t terminate on the slightest provocation.
I would recommend “Thief of Songs”, if you want to read one of her books that doesn’t delve so deeply into angst and dark places. I have read much of what Hogarth has published and liked most of it. There are a few that were tough to get through and I probably would not read again – but am glad that I read at least once and will not forget. I read ”Live,Love,Level” when it came out and really liked it. It is definitely much cozier than anything else she has written, except maybe “Dreamhealers”.
Thanks for this. I am usually not very interested in gaming, so I had overlooked this, but I like Hogarth in general so I will give this a try.
Others by her … you might try Father’s Honor. It assumes as backstory some of the books others have mentioned with angsty and violent sections and an interplanetary war. But the heart of this one is three middle-aged men trying to find their place and their purpose in a changing world. It includes Jahir and Vasiht’h from Dreamhealers, so that might help in picking up the threads. Jahir is recently married to the heir to the Eldritch empire and Vasiht’h has moved most of his family to the Eldritch homeworld, which is opening to the wider galaxy. The three men at the heart of the story are Vasiht’h’s father Petaq, Jahir’s father-in-law Haladir, and Vasiht’h’s former graduate advisor and psych professor Palland.
I think you’ve mentioned that one before, OtterB, and it does sound like just the thing, so thanks for mentioning it again!
I did mention it before. We were talking about fatherhood and the shortage of good images of fathers in SFF. But a lot of books get mentioned here. :)
And if it keeps happening, eventually I think Sure, fine, and pick up the book. Which I did. So now we’ll see whether I read it soon or forget about it and let it drift gently downward through the virtual TBR pile forever …
A griefer is a player who does their best to spoil other players’ fun by wreaking as much destruction as they can. They really exist and they’re horrible.
Thanks, Irina, and yes, that would take a complete jerk.