I tripped over this post, which made me laugh while also making an important point: A reminder about what really matters
There are two “quizzes” below. Scroll slowly and read carefully to get the full effect. Note: It’s okay if you don’t know all the answers, just keep going.
1. Who are the 3 wealthiest writers in the world?
2. Who are the last 3 winners of the Nobel Prize in Literature?
3. Who are the last 3 winners of the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction?
4. What are 5 of the “Top 10 Best Books” of last year?
5. What’s the latest book on shelves that was signed for a 7-figure deal?
***
Okay, how about it? Anybody answer any of those questions, or are they all blank? I bet you can anticipate the second “quiz,” can’t you? Here it is:
***
1. Who are your 3 favorite authors?
2. What are the last 3 books that made you laugh or cry?
3. What are the last 3 books that inspired you?
4. Which 5 books do you most frequently recommend?
5. What’s the last book that you stayed up until the wee hours of the night reading?
The author of the post — an author named Kristan Hoffman — is pushing back against the envy that can beset authors when they hear about prizes awards and big advances and so forth. Good for her.
Mind you, I don’t think I could name “my three favorite authors” because … how could I choose three? I honestly prefer questions phrased with more wiggle room, such as “Who are three of your favorite authors?” That way I feel free to pick three authors without necessarily deciding they’re really THE three. Then I can let the answer change depending on who I thought of at the moment the question was asked — Patricia McKillip, but the other two will probably vary.
Instead of “The last three books that made you laugh or cry,” I would prefer, “What’s one book that made you get up and go find the kleenix?” Then I can say, “The Sky is Everywhere by Jandy Nelson” without feeling like, I mean, am I forgetting something more recent? I can just name something that knocked me out of my chair, even if I read it a long time ago.
I don’t know what the last three books that inspired me would be, but I can say that I’m listening to The Crystal Cave audiobook, and I just hit the conversation between Merlin and Ambrosius, the one right after Merlin realizes Ambrosius is his father, and I thought, I could have written this. I love this. This is exactly how I would have written it. Now I’m thinking maybe this series might have been more influential for me than I ever realized. The description, the pacing, this fantastic, intense conversation, if I met Mary Stewart today, I would say, “Hey, you know what, thanks for writing the Merlin trilogy; I think it might have been a powerful influence on my writing.
The link, by the way, goes to the Chirp audiobook, because that audiobook is still $1.99 as of the time I wrote this post. It might be higher before this post goes live, because I’m going to schedule it for a few days from the time I’m writing this post.
What was the next question? Oh, what are five books that I frequently recommend. Okay, well, it depends on why I’m recommending the book, though! But The Hands of the Emperor is one, especially if someone wants to see great description. So is All Systems Red, for voice and catchiness.
The last question, well, I’m usually pretty committed to turning off the light between nine and ten. The clear awareness that lack of sleep is the single most reliable trigger for headaches means I stick to an extremely consistent schedule. Therefore, I literally don’t remember the last time I stayed up significantly late. It sure doesn’t happen very often.
How about you all? Any of the five questions, pick one and drop a recommendation in the comments.
Also, DOES anybody remember any of the recent winners of the Pulitzer for Fiction? Or whatever. I have no idea about any of those first five questions, and the linked post is right — I also don’t care. That’s as trivial to me as which football team won whatever game last year.
Ok, I looked up all the Pulitzer Prize winners, and the most recent one is ‘James’ a reconsideration of Huckleberry Finn. I have to say, I haven’t read a lot of these books— the last one I read might be Donna Tartt’s book?? Advise and Consent was a favorite, as was The Killer Angels.
In terms of the one book I most recommend, it’s Body and Soul by Frank Conroy. It’s my mother’s recommendation, and everyone who reads it, loves it. It’s the story of a child piano prodigy. I go by my daughter, who is not a reader, but who listens to audiobooks when she travels with her fiancé to Chicago (they loved Tuyo, I think I already told you). They were obsessed with this book. I hope people try it. Also, I hope more people recommend more books!
Tries to find Body and Soul, and The Sky is Everywhere…? What do you mean Amazon’s down???
… different browser works.
If anyone is interested in trying Body and Soul, it’s currently $1.99 for the kindle copy.
I stopped paying attention to book awards decades ago. I think I’ve at least seen a review of “James”, which did not incline me to pick the book up. But then, Huck Finn isn’t a favorite book either. I’ve never finished it. I bounce off the accents. I know Twain knew what he was doing, and I’ve waded through heavily Scots novels as well as other Twains, but something in the way it’s done in HF really doesn’t work for me. I was so lucky it was never assigned reading.
I’ve also read “The Killer Angels”, and found it very good. The sequels not nearly so much.
It’s depressing that I’m having trouble coming up with books to answer the questions.
Not a book, but a Tolkien fanfic, but it does inspire, by the definition of being used as a family shorthand and reference and comparison for all sorts of situations under discussion: A Boy, a Girl, and a Dog, The Leithian Script – The Tale of Tinuviel dramatized script version. Came up twice in the last twenty-four hours, so it’s fresh in mind anyway. Archive of our Own has the most complete version.
Elaine, I also find it depressing that I am having trouble coming up with answers to the questions.
Favorite authors: Martha Wells and Lois McMaster Bujold are my list to preorder without description or blurb; I will read anything they write. There are other authors where I will preorder anything in a particular series or genre but will look closer at other works.
Recent reads I find inspiring: The Hands of the Emperor.
Han Kang is the most recent Nobel awardee! And one whose work I’ve read. I find her books (at least in translation, which is the only way I’ve read them) very beautiful and moving and true, but they are hard reads.
Recommending “favorite” books or even authors is so hard for me, and depends so much on who I’m recommending to. But the last book I stayed up late reading was Naomi Mitchison’s The Oath-Takers, which I think you would like, Rachel. It’s historical fiction a young man, the son of a Frankish nobleman, in ninth-century France and Europe. It’s told in the first person, and the main character and narrative voice actually reminds me a lot of Ryo in the Tuyo books.
I immediately guessed JK Rowling, Stephen King and maybe James Patterson are/were the richest? I do think the really rich ones are so famous you can guess who they are, haha.
It’s funny you said Patricia McKillip, who was my favorite author for most of my life, and Mary Stewart’s Arthurian saga was also very formative for me. Plus you like Ilona Andrews enough to still read them even if you’re tired of the genre. This overlap intuitively makes sense to me because we definitely have a very, very similar aesthetic, even if I judge primarily though your writing. I can usually see a difference between ‘writing I really enjoy’ and ‘writing that heavily shares my quirks and interests’. Writing where I can’t tell anything about my intersection of interests with the author would probably be a) not contemporary; b) very lacking in voice.
I wouldn’t think that normally translates to reading taste, even though I said ‘interests’. That’s kind of broad, like ‘what does the narrative focus on and suggest is important about humanity’, ‘how does the world work according to them’, etc. You can often get a gestalt even through very different POV characters. I often like writing where I can tell we would agree on a lot but have very different perspectives. It’s actually rare to find a lot of similarities (FWIW, Patricia McKillip’s aesthetic is also familiar to me in that sense). Also, I think a lot of times, what writers produce and like to read isn’t the same. Also, maybe you can’t reproduce the stuff you like most (I’d have a very hard time writing action-adventure type stuff).
Anyway, I think it naturally goes the other way– if we like very similar books, we’d probably like each other’s writing (given any decent skill). Even the fact you like discussing/thinking about craft as a hobby (and so do I, but this is far from common in writers) implies something about a common analytical approach that probably filters into writing itself. I tend to like well-written work that’s nevertheless very internally coherent but immediate and immersive, and has a kind of Tolkien-style fairy tale adventure without his actual denseness (so dense epic fantasy authors aren’t my favorites). It’s interesting to think about how taste intersects with writing and how character influences both, anyway :)
I’ve liked some Naomi Mitchison, but hadn’t run across the Oath Takers. I’ve read TRAVEL LIGHT and CORN KING, SPRING QUEEN, which were both good. CKSQ reminded me of some Sutcliff. TL wasn’t what I was expecting, and so I remember less fondly.
Reena, your comment about how you can’t necessarily reproduce the stuff you like most makes me think of trying to write fanfic when I was a kid — this was all in my head, I didn’t write anything down for years and years — but my point is, I absolutely could not capture the voices of other people’s characters, even characters I was very familiar with. I don’t know why. I admire writers who can do that. It’s possible I’d be better able to do it now, though I doubt I’ll ever try. Also, I really admire well-done Historicals, but I doubt very much I’ll ever try to write one. All that research! !!!
It seems a little strange because I’m the exact opposite of analytical as a writer, but yes, pretty analytical when I pause to think about what other authors have done with a book and why that does or does not work well.
Looking up The Oath-Takers and Body and Soul …