I posted a version of this post a long time ago, but the phenomenon of “culling,” and the alternative of “surrender,” still strikes me as both interesting and inevitable. I opt very strongly for “surrender” for some genres, though I’m quite happy to use “culling for others.
Here’s the original post, somewhat revised.
***
Here’s an excellent article at npr.com by Linda Holms.
Surrender, she says, is what you do when you realize that you will never, ever be able to read more than a tiny fraction of the books you would love, and you accept this fact.
Culling is what you do when you declare that all romances / westerns / fantasies / vampire novels are trash and therefore you’re not missing anything when you ignore them. Culling is a psychological trick that protects you from having to acknowledge how much you’re inevitably going to miss.
And Holms says she kind of wonders whether these days there might be a strengthening tendency toward culling:
“What I’ve observed in recent years is that many people, in cultural conversations, are far more interested in culling than in surrender. And they want to cull as aggressively as they can. After all, you can eliminate a lot of discernment you’d otherwise have to apply to your choices of books if you say, “All genre fiction is trash.” You have just massively reduced your effective surrender load, because you’ve thrown out so much at once.”
Well, of course, when *I* cull, it works, because all romances really *are* trash.
Kidding! Kidding! I like plenty of romances! It just took me a while to realize that, because there are so many I don’t like.
Of course you can’t read everything, or even a significant minority of everything, and naturally it’s helpful to narrow your attention down to those chunks of everything in which you’re more likely to find things you really do love . . . but there’s no question that every single time you declare a genre or subgenre not-of-interest and ignore it, you’re setting yourself up to miss those parts of it you really would love.
I do think that this is the exact problem — the problem of finding things you’d love when they’re not in genres you’re focused on — that online book review sites such as The Book Smugglers address, and that the need for great (and prolific) reviewers will become more and more important as self-publishing rises and the enormous pool of books we’d love becomes ever more diluted by the far more immense ocean of books we’d hate.
I don’t really follow any book review blogs anymore, because my TBR pile is so massive that I just can’t face adding heaps more books to it. But, at the time I first posted about this, I bought The Sky is Everywhere and Five Flavors of Dumb because of Ana’s reviews at The Book Smugglers blog. Five Flavors was fine, but The Sky is Everywhere was fantastic and definitely one of my favorite books of those I read that year. And I wouldn’t have ever noticed either if I’d declared contemporary YA and YA romances uninteresting — as Holms puts it, if I’d culled those categories. So put me down on the side of just surrendering to the knowledge that it’s impossible to read everything I’d love.
I, of course, cheat: I draw a massive proportion of the books I read and of my TBR pile from your comments here. It’s quite rare I pick up any new-to-me author in any other way. It can happen, but it doesn’t happen often. This suggests that a pool of social contacts who share your broad tastes in books is an alternative means of finding books you’d love amid the vast and growing ocean of available titles.
The other main way I pick up titles — this doesn’t happen often — is that I happen to get a promotional email from BookBub or someone when I have nothing much going on and I actually open the email and look at it. Then it’s possible I’ll click through to some book or other and take a better look. I don’t pick up many books that way even if they’re free because I’m long past the stage where I’d pick up a book that looked iffy just because it’s free. I HAVE a giant TBR pile. I hardly read ANYTHING by ANYONE these days. I don’t need or want to pile more books on top. But, on the other hand, occasionally I do pick p a book that way. Then it goes on the “someday” list along with everything else.
However, it’s occurred to me, as I update this post, that it’s also possible to do effective culling — not so much by genre, maybe, but by tone. Like this: I will never like anything grimdark, ever, and there’s absolutely no need for me to try any sample of any book that is grimdark or closely adjacent to grimdark.
Boom! That took out quite a broad swathe of fantasy and a chunk of various other genres, and it was both easy and accurate. I mean, I really don’t see how ANY author could EVER make me like anything grimdark. That’s quite different from writing off a whole genre, or so it seems to me.
However, I basically have no problem acknowledging that I will never read most of the great books I would love passionately. That’s just inevitable. Even more so for games I will never play and TV shows and movies I’ll never watch. Unless someone gets hopping with a youthening treatment that hands me an extra few hundred years, there’s no way, and that’s the way it is.
I agree – that’s pretty much how I approach it too. Genre tells you what a book is about, but not what it’s like (tone, themes, etc). I also cull anything with “harrowing” in the blurb. I don’t need to be harrowed.
I wonder if it’d be interesting to compare what other words are turnoffs? Not as definitive as harrowing, but also highly suspicious of any blurbs with the words tragic/tragedy, struggle, and compelling. I also don’t really forgive typos/grammatical errors in blurbs – every book has some that slip through, and I am pretty lax about that, but they should be able to get a couple paragraphs right.
I made a conscious decision to stop reading contemporary romance years ago. Partly this was because of the rise of paranormal romance which I liked better, but mostly it was because the contemporary blurbs failed to excite me. It began to feel like I’d read them all before. And while I knew that individual authors take on the story would probably be gripping enough to hold me I stopped wanting to give them that chance (with the exception of some trusted authors whom I still read.)
Culling implies that the genre was ever under consideration as candidates.
Since you liked my fairytale fantasies in the past, I offer one for consideration or culling:
The Enchanted Princess Wakes
(I talk about it and offer other venues here.)
I will never ever like anything grimdark. I’m okay with bad things happening in a story – like, oh, Lorellan – but make that the ENTIRE STORY and I’m outta there. Make the story about a good sorcerer coming down like a ton of bricks on evil Lord Lorellan and I’m along for that ride. (And yes, I do realise that this is simplifying the plot thread massively. I’m also assuming that pretty much everybody reading Rachel’s blog will have read Tuyo, but trying not to spoil too badly anyway.)
“Supernatural” is an entire-genre cull for me. I gave Black Dog a go because if anybody could have written an exception it was Rachel and she had #1 on a Free Sale, but I didn’t like it and quit not far in. But then, Horror is also a genre-cull, which Supernatural probably shares (slightly) more kinship with than Fantasy. Horror has two exceptions, though: the book “The Phantom of the Opera” in German translation, and the film “The Sixth Sense”. But every other time I’ve deliberately or accidentally tried anything horror-adjacent – graphic novels are HELL for accidentally-trying that, by the way; I did it with two different books by different authors which BOTH looked like they were fantasy!!! – it was not a good experience. It took me MONTHS to forget the first third-or-so of the original Dracula (which I tried deliberately, in an attempt to figure out whether it was simply *modern* horror that I disliked. Answer: no).
Romance is a funny one for me. I have read enough romance where I couldn’t care less about the characters that it’s a turnoff to the entire genre, even though I try to avoid romance as a general rule! (There is SO MUCH fiction that could have been good if there wasn’t a romance shoved in there stuffing it up.) However, IN SAYING THAT, I am very fond of fairytale retellings… which are basically all romance-centric in some way. The difference there is that there’s usually something far more interesting going on that the stupid romance – i.e. magic, curses, dragons, talking cats, basically anything except the stupid romance… Although again, there are exceptions. It’s just that a romance that has nothing fantasy going for it *really* has to have well-rounded characters to attract my esteem. And most straight romance I’ve tried simply doesn’t give me enough character depth to care one bit about the people falling in love. Or it does give me character depth and I promptly end up detesting one or both of them. There have been a very, very, very few romance books that I have liked, and only one of *them* had it as the main point(ish).
Fantasy is the section I’m most likely to hang out in, the one where I’ll pick up a book and read the blurb and think “this sounds interesting; let’s give it a whirl”. I’ve found some odd gems that way. The Misenchanted Sword, last year. The Long Way To A Small Angry Planet, two years ago. Magic Kingdom For Sale/Sold when I was nine – at which point I went careening into the Adult Fantasy section; it was misshelved as Childrens at the book sale and it was the best misshelving of my life. Alphabet of Thorn, which attracted my attention because of the title – at which point I started to devour every Patricia McKillip the public library had in stock… although that started when I was about eleven, so whether I *followed the plotline* was about a 50/50 split. It was a very good thing that that *particular* McKillip caught my eye first, because it’s one of her easiest.
(In contrast, I wouldn’t even get as far as the blurb with anything Clearly Horror, and for Romance the blurb would have to be “this sounds absolutely fascinating and I’d really like to know what the author does with this” – and even then, 19 times out of 20, it’s a disappointment).
Heather, I’m entertained by the idea that Alphabet of Thorn is one of McKillip’s easiest. I wouldn’t say that at all! Although I think the ending is clear, which I DON’T think is true for some of my personal favorites of hers.
I felt EXACTLY the same way about romance for ages. “Ho hum, they’re sweet, I’m sure it will work out, can we have a plot in here somewhere?” was pretty much my take on contemporary romance in particular, though setting matters to me so much that sometimes historical romance would work for me. But it turned out that if I like the characters and the writing enough, I’m okay with the romance being the most important thing in the story. I would say that Softly Falling by Carla Kelly was perfect for me as a romance — setting, check; enough plot, check; great characters, check.
I respond to grimdark exactly as you respond to horror. I wish I could scrub it out of my brain.