Bad Writing

I have to admit, I do sometimes enjoy reading a well-written, highly negative book review. This one in particular interests me because it’s not a book review; it’s an analysis of the opening prologue.

Lessons From the Bad Writing of When the Moon Hatched

When the Moon Hatched is a traditionally published bestselling fantasy novel, and honestly, right off the bat, I do have this reaction to it:

Because for crying out loud, big publishers are supposed to have a clue and it’s just painful to see a terribly written history-lesson prologue in this book. No wonder so many aspiring self-publishing authors ask questions like, “Do I have to have a prologue in a fantasy novel?” and think that this kind of prologue is either just fine or actually required.

Actually, the reviewer at the linked post thinks some of the prologue is beautifully written. I don’t. I think all of the prologue is badly written and some of it is excruciatingly badly written.

The world began with five.

First was Caelis, God of Aether, invisible to the naked eye. The empty space no one thought about. Where matter formed, he was simply shoved aside.

His baritone song was so full of substance, yet lacked it entirely. A lonely echo that haunted the empty space between near and distant suns—inaudible in its depth, no matter how loud he sang.

Desperate to be noticed, it was he who offered an empty canvas for the others to fill.

***

I’m done already. Actually, I was done, let me see, one and a half lines into this prologue. But if I’d gotten this far, I would now be done. There is literally nothing I like in the above, plus give me a break, the first god’s defining characteristic is desperation to be noticed.

The author really means it, too:

Others fell upon a silver book some say Caelis wrote in his desperation to be heard. Who found a different form of power in those runes nobody could read or pronounce, discovering that the strange markings could be wielded. Could mend bones, charm blood, glamor objects …

His desperation to be heard. Just kill me now.

Here’s a bit more of the prologue, without snarky commentary, so you can judge for yourself, not that I haven’t biased your perceptions, probably, but you can see what you think. Italics are in the original.

***

***

The world began with five.

First was Caelis, God of Aether, invisible to the naked eye. The empty space no one thought about. Where matter formed, he was simply shoved aside.

His baritone song was so full of substance, yet lacked it entirely. A lonely echo that haunted the empty space between near and distant suns—inaudible in its depth, no matter how loud he sang.

Desperate to be noticed, it was he who offered an empty canvas for the others to fill.

Bulder, God of Ground, sculpted the sphere with one belted bellow, building a sturdy globe that did not spin. A world half bathed in sunlight, sprinkled with a rich ripple of rust-colored sand, the other half eternally dunked in shadow so thick it seeped into the stone and cast it black. 

With more blunt and droning words, Bulder sculpted the terrain, creating dips, dollops, and cracks in the world. Forging a wall that cut through the Fade — where sunlight and shadow refused to meet — the sky a forever splash of pink, purple, and gold.

The Goddess of Water came next.

Rayne fell upon the ground in a billion yearning teardrops of unrequited love, puddling in Bulder’s dips, filling his gorges with her gushing affections. Upon the shaded side, she descended in a patter of heavy flakes, dusting the sharp mountain ranges in a frosty hug.

Her love was a screaming torrent. The deep, gut-wrenching wail of an avalanche. The near-silent cry of sprinkling rain.

Her mournful song was so unlike that of her sister Clode—Goddess of Air—who hinged on the precipice of immeasurable madness. Her voice was a ribbon of silk, soft to touch, unless it turned to the side and slit you with its edge. 

Her whispered words swept past branches laden with leaves, tilling them into a flirty dance. Her violent shrieks ripped around sharp corners at a voracious speed simply because she liked the sound. Unable to stand Rayne’s somber still, Clode’s gusty howls often churned the Loff into a heaving mass that dumped upon the shore like a drum.

Ignos was a glutton for Clode. The God of Fire feasted on her. Consumed her. 

Loved her so much he could not breathe without her.

***

There you are. That’s the whole prologue. Various reviews at Amazon mention the great writing. The snarky critique I originally linked says:

There are many beautiful passages with evocative phrasing and lovely imagery.

And I really, really wonder where those beautiful passages are, because I’m not seeing them. This is aside from the annoying tendency to make Every. Single. Sentence. Into. Its. Own. Paragraph. Which is barely an exaggeration, and of course looks worse when spacing between paragraphs, which is how WordPress wants to do it, so avoiding that is a pain and a half, but admittedly that does make this tendency to super-short paragraphs look worse and more extreme than in the real world. But my point is, I’m seeing a LOT of clumsy, awkward, inferior writing here. A LOT. And how is it possible the reviewer who critiques it doesn’t see that?

His baritone song was so full of substance, yet lacked it entirely. What?

no matter how loud he sang. You mean “loudly”?

eternally dunked in shadow so thick it seeped into the stone and cast it black.  “Dunked”? “Cast it black”?

dips, dollops, and cracks in the world. “Dollops,” really?

Rayne fell upon the ground in a billion yearning teardrops of unrequited love, puddling in Bulder’s dips, filling his gorges with her gushing affections. I can’t bear it.

The deep, gut-wrenching wail of an avalanche. Avalanches wail?

On and on, I see a handful of sentences that don’t strike me as painful, but MOSTLY this is painful to read. 35,000 ratings on Amazon. 4.4 average star rating. I just … the editor at whatever publisher — oh, Avon, which is an imprint of Harper Collins — anyway, to be fair, the editor did her job, which was to recognize a book that had the potential to be catchy and package it up in a way that would sell. Good for her, I guess, but I wish she had failed to make this sell, because it’s not great to see something as badly written as this jump to the top of the bestseller lists. I realize tastes differ, but honestly.

The linked post also says:

The prologue serves the story by getting world explanations out of the way and setting up the story’s throughline.

And I am here to declare that you should not need to explain the world and you most emphatically should not need to “get the world explanation out of the way,” for crying out loud, stop that. How about you integrate the worldbuilding into the story as you write it, the way every good author actually does it, and this kind of explanation of the world’s mythology is lazy as well as boring, even if it is well written, which this one is not.

The linked post finishes:

This prologue is simply not a replacement for actually starting the story, for meeting the main character and forcing that main character to deal with a threat. Ideally, Parker would sketch out the basics of the world – eternal day and night, the dragons – while that happens. That depends on putting the main character in the right situation to start. You don’t want a first scene where nothing happens just so you can explain the world. But it’s usually possible to choose a good opening problem that also lets you show the world off.

Yeah, what she said.

Although I wouldn’t say I’ve NEVER seen a mythology-of-the-world prologue that worked for me — I might have seen one I loved and forgotten about it — I can say that I don’t REMEMBER ever seeing one that I thought was a good idea, while I’ve seen a fair number, including some by well-known and popular authors, that were terrible plus completely unnecessary. This is another one like that.

Here are the first sentences of chapter one:

I curl my shoulders forward, crumbling my posture into something that appears trodden.

Scared.

Just skip the prologue, stop right here after the first fourteen words of the actual story, and try to tell me this book is well-written. Because if anybody thinks wow, such great writing, I swear, I will just give up.

Please Feel Free to Share:

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedintumblrmail

10 thoughts on “Bad Writing”

  1. “Ignos was a glutton for Clode.” Please no.
    The aggressive alliteration was also really aggravating me.

  2. Terribly overblown, full of very strange and illogical comparisons and weird word choices, and trying way too hard to be ‘precious’ and ‘clever’ and ‘poetical’ with all the farfetched alliteration forcing the strange word choices.
    Very offputting to read.

  3. Agreed with all above. And it was giving me a sense of ‘inspired by’ Elder Scrolls setting. (Which I don’t actually play but the Teen does and likes to discuss the lore. ) Overall got a sense of a bad fanfiction where the writer doesn’t understand the world or anything.

    I am boggled at so many people saying the writing is good, great, or beautiful. Sentence fragments do not make it beautiful. Or perhaps those who describe it favorably have been immersed in modern ‘poetry’ which has tends to sentence fragments, judging by the samples I’ve seen. And poetry is supposed to be beautiful therefore this writing which reminds me of the poetry I have read and been taught is good and beautiful must also be good and beautiful. But that’s a guess.

    Best sellers don’t actually have to sell much these days. I remember KK Rusch some years back referencing information that you can get on the NYT list for something like five thousand sales.

    Just for fun, here’s the opening of The DaVinci Code which I called out earlier this week as a bestseller with poor writing – the one title I could actually remember of the books I’ve browsed:

    “Renowned curator Jacques Sauniere staggered through the vaulted archway of the museum’s Grand Gallery. He lunged for the nearest painting he could see, a Caravaggio. Grabbing the gilded frame, the seventy-six-year-old man heaved the masterpiece toward himself until it tore from the wall and Sauniere collapsed backward in a heap beneath the canvas.”

    It’s not great, but it’s better than this current sample. Different genre, but still. It’s flat, but has some flow.

    The Teen just wandered through and suggested posting the opening of The Honeycomb which I also mentioned earlier this week and has good writing:

    When the Nine Worlds were still very young, there were no stories. There was only Dream, the river that runs through all the worlds, reflecting the hearts and desires of the Folk on its journey towards pandemonium.

  4. Wow, that was bad. I’ve got very low tolerance for bad prose. I always look at the preview/sample of the book before buying. If I open a book and something like that appears, it’s a dealbreaker. No way I’m downloading, even if it’s free!

    I’ve had a lot of success filtering books this way. The only time it’s failed me has been when the first part seemed fine, and then for some reason the writing deteriorated a lot after. It’s only happened a couple of times, but it was disappointing. Maybe they really worked at and polished the first few paragraphs/chapter, and then somehow ran out of steam? They could only afford an editor for the first few chapters? It’s a mystery!

  5. I’ve long felt people (readers) fall into different camps. Some (most) are readers but not Readers; that is, reading is something they so lightly and casually and perhaps limited to the popular or well-marketed thing. They don’t necessarily have a sense for prose whatsoever. This is usually reflected in the fact that most super popular writing has very, very clear but striking prose. The stuff that’s both popular in its time and lastingly famous tends to have clear prose that is *also* brilliantly vivid and metaphorically rich. This is the case when readers are joined by Readers (nerdy fans) and academics. Shakespeare is like that. Still popular to this day! Very clear even in older English, IMO. And yet his prose often makes me shudder at its brilliance, to the point of actual awe. I think his writing is beautiful and terrible, in that old sense of terrifying beauty. This is very rare. Very.

    And yet, people want to write beautifully. They think writing clearly is not impressive or suitable for fantasy. And coincidentally, readers (not Readers, but there’s few enough of those) are easily impressed by writing that requires what they think of as skill. That is, skill at using a thesaurus. They don’t know this or that word, or they wouldn’t have said that themselves. Ergo, it is fancy. Fancy is good. Fancy is… fancy. High class, even. This creates a market for bad writing of this sort, especially if it’s well-marketed. Essentially, people who are not themselves good at writing cannot truly judge what is good, only what is impressive to them. Knowing when something is truly well-done ultimately requires some skill in that activity.

    So how do people know Shakespeare is good? IMO, partly it’s that most people *don’t* know– they only know his reputation, and that he’s supposed to be very good, and that’s enough. And like I said, he writes clearly, and he’s entertaining, so people enjoy it. It’s fun *and* simply reading or watching his works confers certain status. Win win. People who can recognize skill also enjoy it, on a different (complementary) level. The more you know about stories and writing, the more levels you have for enjoying it. That applies to anything that can be academically studied but also enjoyed, really.

    Anyway, your average person knows shit all about writing. Many/most popular mass market books play to that by putting out very clear prose and linear plots, exciting storylines and so on. God, have you ever read a Patterson book? His chapters are like, literally two pages, written on a third grade reading level, even if it’s YA. And I think this is the flipside. Most readers aren’t really looking for genuinely complex prose in a YA fantasy novel (that’s left for literary fiction). But the desire to feel smart and cultured is there, on the reader’s part *and* the writer’s part, so it’s self-reinforcing. This is why a lot of the images seem like nonsense. A garbled mix of words meant to give a certain impression. Like q McMansion, hehe.

  6. Avoid putting metaphysics into your stories as much as possible. Besides being a dreadful opportunity to show off the depths of your shallowness — really, there’s a lot of good thinking about metaphysics out there, and that’s what you’ll be compared to — it deprives the characters of legitimate differences of opinion.

  7. That was DIRELY bad. I couldn’t even get to the end of it. (I lost it at Rayne the rain god and SHEESH, use a little imagination!!!!) Too much infodumping and what, EXACTLY, does any of it have to do with the actual story? (In other words, why should I care one iota about it?)

    Yeah… that book wouldn’t be for me. That book would be Quit After Sentence Five. (Sentences 1 through 4 could have been an okay start to a send-up of this sort of thing. But then Sentence 5 and no, this is just really crappy writing.)

    Also, I love beautiful writing. That was not it. Beautiful writing also communicates clearly. It’s fine if it’s beautiful AND “hard but possible to understand”, if the author knows what they’re saying and the reader can mostly grasp it even if it has to be with the aid of a dictionary the first time round… (Avram Davidson, aaaargh! He said EXACTLY what he meant and said it beautifully… but some of the language he used was oldfangled fifty years ago when he wrote the story and is “… okay, I have never seen that word in my life! What…?” now. I can’t stick with him for more than a five page story but OH are the best of those pages ever wonderful.) But this one… was the writer throwing darts at a dictionary? It’s incomprehensible!

  8. When I was a kid, I pretty much always skipped the prologues – I just thought they were supposed to be optional, since nothing important ever happened in them.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top