Okay, so I’ve been thinking recently about big topics – I mean passion and power, depth and resonance. I’ve been thinking about how these big qualities work in fiction. I’m thinking about the creation of truth in fiction. About how one novel can feel like a popcorn read or a beach read – shallow, light, trivial – while other novels can feel powerful and true. Or, for that matter, powerful but false. I’ve happened across various novels this year that made me think of this, with one being The Ocean and the Stars, as I mentioned in a recent post.
Power and resonance isn’t an adventure vs interior journey type of distinction. It’s more a shallow vs. deep distinction, but I don’t think that’s really what’s going on either. I may be biased by the strong (very strong) cultural tendency to assume that joyful means shallow while depressed means deep, which is a notion that is both wrong and pernicious, but I don’t think that’s it.
Notice that I declared that the idea that joyful = shallow while depressed = deep is wrong and pernicious. I don’t feel any great need to argue about this, or justify the statement, or back away and say something tentative and cautious. I didn’t say in my opinion. I mean, I’d be fine arguing about this, I would enjoy that argument under the right circumstances, but I don’t feel it’s necessary to proactively take a defensive stance. I can and do just say, That’s not only wrong, it’s wrong in a harmful way. That’s because if someone disagrees, I don’t really care. This is something I’ve thought about enough that I’m not at all likely to change my mind. I’m confident I’m right about this.
I think this is also true: authorial confidence leads to power in fiction. Power is not about truth. It’s about conviction. In order to write something with power, the author has to be confident they’re saying something that is worth saying.
At the end of RIHASI when Marathani says to Rihasi, “It’s a wonderful play. And do you know why? Because it’s about someone doing something difficult and dangerous and worth doing.” – that’s a very meta statement, and I recognized that when I put that line into the story. This wasn’t just something one character was saying to another. This was also me, declaring, “This right here, this story you’ve read, is a good story, because it’s about someone doing something difficult and dangerous and worth doing.” I was also saying, “A story will be better – more true, more powerful – if it’s about people who do things that are difficult and dangerous and worth doing. A story isn’t likely to be all that great if it’s not about that.” I’m confident this is true. That’s why my novels are about that. That’s why they’re the antithesis of grimdark, where the author is saying, “Life is brutal; there’s no point striving to make the world into a better place or yourself into a better person; you can’t succeed; everything will get worse forever.” A novel like that can be powerful if the author writes with conviction, which is why power and truth are not the same thing.
Whether a story is true at its heart or false, it’s authorial confidence that leads to thematic coherence, because the author is in fact saying something. It might be true or otherwise, but it’s something that the author wants to say and they’re saying it with conviction and they want you, the reader, to hear what they’re saying beneath the words on the page. Hearing the themes below the words is what we mean by resonance. This story really resonated with me means I felt this story was true to my life, or I felt this story was about something true.
Authorial skill also matters. Lack of skill with storytelling is what causes message fiction to lose power. That’s because power in fiction depends on telling a story that resonates, and when fiction delivers a sermon rather than telling a story, then it loses power even if the message is a good one. Therefore, power in fiction depends on the ability to tell a story with conviction, not just to deliver a message with conviction. This is also why some authors say, “I’m just writing to entertain! I’m just telling stories!” while they write stories that capture truth. When Lois McMaster Bujold has Ekaterin say to a younger woman, “Adulthood is not a good conduct prize you win by being a good child,” she’s said something true. (Bujold is really good at witty one-liners that capture something true.) Stories that are light in tone can still resonate because the author is writing with conviction at the thematic level. Terry Pratchett exemplifies this kind of writer. I bet he never once apologized for a single line he wrote – certainly not by the time he was writing social satire disguised as light fantasy.
Power also depends on skill with the prose. Various qualities are important for prose to become infused with power: rhythm, allusion, precision, vividness, density of meaning, ability to evoke the scene and create a world that the reader feels is real. It seems to me – notice that I’m being cautious here; I’m not as confident about this – but it seems to me that some readers are able to read past less skilled prose, seeing the themes below the story even when the prose is not that great, and that therefore these readers can experience a story as powerful when I probably wouldn’t. Even so, I do think skill with sentence-level and paragraph-level craft is important in creating a story that will resonate, that will feel true, for many or most readers.
But, along with both storytelling craft and sentence-level craft, power absolutely requires confidence on the part of the author. This is one big reason I detest questions about writing that go, “Is it okay if I write about [whatever]?” You just absolutely cannot ask for permission to write the story you want to write. You absolutely have to decide to tell the story you want to tell, the way you want to tell it, because you are not going to be able to write with any power while you are hunched into a defensive ball in case some reader somewhere might someday be offended.
Nor do you need to worry about whether you have something worth saying. Who knows? Put that out of your mind and just write the story you want to write. Write a story to entertain, that’s absolutely fine. If you write the story you actually want to write, I expect something true will probably turn out to be in that story. If readers declare that the story resonates or is meaningful or that the world desperately needs more stories just like yours, then you can be sure of it, even if you’re still feeling your way into the themes that matter to you as a writer. If the story is in fact shallow and light and fluffy, well, the world needs light entertainment too. But I sort of suspect that if you have something to say, it’ll turn out to be there, under the fluff. That’s why, even if you say, “I’m just writing to entertain!” you should strive to write that entertaining story as well as you possibly can.
Coming up: Various blog posts about powerful novels. I’m not going to say, “novels that I personally think are powerful.” I’m just going to say flatly, These are novels that are powerful, and I assume everyone will get that I mean that’s my personal opinion since this is my personal blog. I don’t think everyone in the universe will agree, but regardless, I’m confident I am indeed right.
I appreciate your conviction, and I do believe you’re right. Powerful novels don’t necessarily have to have true ideas, but to resonate with someone they absolutely must at least FEEL true.
That being said, I think that the most powerful novels I have ever encountered did, indeed, resonate because they said something true with absolute confidence.
“. . . For heroes, life is a weapon, a thing to be spent, a gift to be given to the weak and the lost and the weary . . . Love burns hotter than justice, and its roar is thunder. Beside love, even wrath whispers . . . Our goal was never to live; our goal is to love. It is the goal of all truly noble men and women. Give all that can be given. Give even your life itself . . .”
Empire of Bones, N.D. Wilson
“‘I wish it need not have happened in my time,’ said Frodo.
‘So do I,’ said Gandalf, ‘and so do all who live to see such times. But that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us . . .'”
The Fellowship of the Ring, J.R.R. Tolkien
Rachel, I am looking forward to your series of posts about powerful novels. I find it interesting that your post and E.C.’s comment both pull out heroism as a defining characteristic. “Doing something difficult and dangerous and worth doing” is a definition of heroism to my mind. I also think heroism is the biggest theme of The Lord of the Rings, which I find to be a very powerful novel despite its flaws. As we look at more examples, it will be interesting to see if different themes can also make a novel powerful, or if heroism is an essential element.
Agree completely! As you say, Terry Pratchett is a great example of writing with conviction and saying true things (lightly disguised as fantasy). Also one of the few authors I felt kept getting better in his Discworld series. And I think he actually gets the economics right in Going Postal, which is pretty amazing. All in all, being able to explain the economics of monetary systems in an accessible way, while providing powerful social commentary, all in the form of a very entertaining fantasy story, is astonishing. Deep understanding combined with conviction and great craft = powerful novel. And as you say, it doesn’t have to be depressing to be powerful. A close friend of mine, when he was dying with cancer, reread the entire Discworld series as the last series he would ever read. What a tribute.
I ran across this essay on earnestness and it connected in my mind with what you are saying. https://www.paulgraham.com/earnest.html
The author is talking about founders of Silicon Valley startups and the contribution of earnestness to success. He defines earnestness as wanting to solve the problem or learn the material for its own sake, not to be cool or performative. This seems analogous to writing the story you want to write.
I look forward to your posts on powerful novels. I think both Bujold and Pratchett make good examples.
OtterB, THAT makes me think of my younger brother learning programming with a Commodore 64 and teaching himself whatever computer languages were current at the time. He’s a computer guy now, he does stuff I know nothing about. At some point it occurred to me, when I was working with students taking classes related to computers and programming: You are going to be competing with people like my brother, who learned this for fun when they were twelve years old. You are never, ever going to be even a fraction as god at this if you are treating the material as a hoop to jump through so you can get a job.
I’m not sure I’d call that earnestness. Enthusiasm? Intrinsic interest and motivation?
Intrinsic motivation, certainly.
The essay author was talking primarily about people who were starting businesses and the difference between those who started a business because they wanted to solve a particular problem, and those who started one because they wanted to make money. There’s nothing at all wrong, he says, with wanting your startup to make money. But people who only want that tended to be less successful.
I have mixed feelings about how this applies to people who aren’t the business owner. I tend to agree that people like your brother who are learning skills because they like them will have an edge on those who don’t. My husband had a couple of class projects in science classes that were labors of love and far outstripped anything a teacher would reasonably expect.
But … there’s something wrong with employers demanding that job applicants who have the necessary skills also have (or fake) a passion for the work.
Which I suppose is irrelevant to the original point about writing powerful novels. I think that a writer with good craft could write a perfectly acceptable novel without having that level of enthusiasm, especially a fluffy one or part of a series that has a pattern to it. But I think it would be hard to write a powerful novel without it speaking your truth.
Otterb,
I agree that someone who has no passion for writing will probably write a perfectly serviceable novel, that will probably not be re-read material. Someone who has a message to share through said novel will do it more or less well, but that mostly results in message fiction, which is not fun to read (for me; I’m sure someone out there enjoys it).
Someone who has a passion for writing AND a deep interest in something (Language, for Tolkien, or for Pratchett, social issues and economics) will probably write something that is enjoyable reading and also true to their interests – and thus, powerful.
Melanie,
I think that there are plenty of themes that make powerful novels. The Brothers Karamazov, for example, is all about how people come to make choices, good or bad – actually, many great Russian novels deal with this theme. The Count of Monte Christo is, in part, about choosing to let go of a deep-seated and entirely reasonable grudge. Whereas one of my favorite ‘cozy’ series, Galleries of Stone, is entirely about family relationships. Though I wouldn’t call it ‘powerful’, exactly, it is one of those series that I reread regularly. And the Death’s Lady books have a powerful theme of redemption. Not all of those map precisely onto heroism, necessarily, though they can certainly be aspects of a heroic story.
You make a lot of great points here! Joyful vs depressing, powerful and/or resonant, the importance of thought and conviction, storytelling craft and prose. I was thinking about message fiction not so long ago, and I like the distinction you’ve drawn that message fiction is about delivering a sermon rather than telling a story. That really encompasses the difference for me, like those works aren’t story enough.
E.C., that Tolkien quote is the one that’s stayed with me the most.
OtterB, thanks for the link. An interesting look at both earnestness and startups. Also, that fake passion thing is so annoying.
Hmm. I thought of this:
The next real literary “rebels” in this country might well emerge as some weird bunch of anti-rebels, born oglers who dare somehow to back away from ironic watching, who have the childish gall actually to endorse and instantiate single-entendre principles. Who treat of plain old untrendy human troubles and emotions in U.S. life with reverence and conviction. Who eschew self-consciousness and hip fatigue. These anti-rebels would be outdated, of course, before they even started. Dead on the page. Too sincere. Clearly repressed. Backward, quaint, naive, anachronistic. Maybe that’ll be the point. Maybe that’s why they’ll be the next real rebels. Real rebels, as far as I can see, risk disapproval. The old postmodern insurgents risked the gasp and squeal: shock, disgust, outrage, censorship, accusations of socialism, anarchism, nihilism. Today’s risks are different. The new rebels might be artists willing to risk the yawn, the rolled eyes, the cool smile, the nudged ribs, the parody of gifted ironists, the “Oh how banal”. To risk accusations of sentimentality, melodrama. Of overcredulity. Of softness. Of willingness to be suckered by a world of lurkers and starers who fear gaze and ridicule above imprisonment without law. Who knows. David Foster Wallace
Mary, I genuinely feel that the statement, “Oh, how banal” is diagnostic of a terrible modern attitude that combines an air of superiority with a serious lack of anything to feel superior about. When someone says — I don’t know where this observation came from originally — that the defining characteristic of the age is that we are condescended to by our inferiors, this is the exact attitude I’m thinking of.
I don’t have anything smart to add, but I did want to say I enjoyed this post a lot & am excited about the idea of posts on specific powerful novels (in case it’s useful to have blog topic feedback).
It’s very helpful, Kate, thank you!