From BookRiot, this post by Anmanda Nelson, about YA and adult fantasy titles that go well together, in the sense that if you liked this, you should perhaps try that.
As it happens, though, I haven’t read any of the titles Amanda picked. Well, okay, yes I have: I’ve read Sabriel, but I had to look twice to notice because that’s the only one; it was a long time ago and I must admit I don’t remember anything about it. Yes, I know, lots of people love Sabriel. Someday I will probably re-read it. Let’s see, okay, her choices were:
The Walls Around Us by Nova Ren Suma and The Robber Bride by Margaret Atwood
The Agency series by Y.S. Lee and The Fair Fight by Anna Freeman
Sabriel by Garth Nix and The Queen of the Tearling by Erika Johansen
Complicit by Stephanie Kuehn and Sharp Objects by Gillian Flynn
Shatter Me series by Tahereh Mafi and The Last Werewolf by Glen Duncan
Most of them, I don’t think I’d want to read, based on Amanda’s descriptions and the fact that I really disliked A Handmaid’s Tale. (I read it a long time ago, I admit, maybe I would like it better now.)
I found the second set in particular an interesting contrast:
Lee’s Agency series follows Mary, a young thief in Victorian England rescued from the gallows and trained to be a female private investigator and spy. Her job places her in a number of situations a lady wouldn’t normally find herself in- a similar theme in The Fair Fight, a brilliant novel about female bare-knuckle boxing during the same time frame. Ruth and Mary are both poor, outcasts, and take to untraditional livelihoods to stay afloat. The adult-ness of the Freeman book means it’s dirtier and grittier (and has much fouler language), so it’s easy to pick which one you want to read based on how much dirt you want under your nails.
The first sounds like a story I would like. The second, not so much. I can see why Amanda paired them off, but I’m not sure the pairing works terribly well for me.
But it’s an interesting idea! Even though I don’t really believe in the actual YA category as such, here are five YA titles I particularly love:
Beauty by Robin McKinley
The Scorpio Races by Maggie Stiefvater
The Dark is Rising by Susan Cooper
The Queen’s Thief series by Megan Whelan Turner
The Tiffany series by Terry Pratchett
And what the heck, also:
The Floating Islands
Now, what adult titles would you pair with those? Here are my suggestions, and I am trying here to pick books that really and truly might not appeal to younger readers but might to older readers:
Beauty . . . . Enchantment by Orson Scott Card. Why I picked it: it’s a fairy tale, but a good deal longer, slower, and more complicated than McKinley’s story. It’s one of the later books by OSC that suggests to me that he can still really tell a story (I was not too keen on some of his later books, but this one is very well put together.)
The Scorpio Races . . . Rider at the Gate by CJ Cherryh. Why I picked it: This is a far cry from the wish-fulfillment magical horse of fantasy. Rider is by no means my favorite CJC title, but wow, the predatory horse thing is even more intense than in Stiefvater’s book. I may never read the sequel again . . . unless she writes a third book . . . but I will certainly read the first one again; it stands alone fairly well.
The Dark is Rising . . . The Anubis Gates by Tim Powers. Why I picked it: I was thinking about books with a time travel element, but with a more immersive feel than Connie Willis’ Blackout/All Clear had for me. And Powers is a spectacularly gifted writer, even if he’s not one of my personal favorites.
The Queen’s Thief . . . The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch. Why I picked it: thieves, thieves, let’s see. I mean, there’s no shortage of thieves in fantasy. Lynch’s series is well written, gritty but not TOO dark, definitely not something I would hand a kid but definitely something I would recommend to adults.
The Tiffany series . . . the Sam Vimes series. Is it cheating to pick another series by the same author? And I grant you, this series, at least once you get past the first one, probably appeals to practically everyone.
The Floating Islands . . . The Raksura novels (and stories) by Martha Wells. Flying! People! I am pretty sure I would have LOVED the Raksura novels whether I’d first read them at fourteen or forty, but they jumped out at me for this comparison even though I think many younger readers would love them.
Okay! What is your favorite YA, or even MG, title? And what adult title would you suggest might go with it?