Okay, so I’m still having trouble with comments, so if you have a comment, please email me at firstname.lastname@example.org and I’ll post it myself, okay? The problem is being worked on, so hopefully it’ll be fixed soon.
Mary Beth emailed me a comment about Cherryh’s “horses” in the CLOUD’S RIDER duology as aliens (though not quite sentient, maybe).
Though I did like the horses in those books (“I want bacon!”), this duology wasn’t my favorite of Cherryh’s work, and I said so, and we had a conversation about dangerous carnivorous horses compared to My Pretty Pony Pal horses in fantasy, and about Cherryh in general, and I realized that really there have been quite a few Cherryh books that were not my favorites. So, here’s my top five picks for Cherryh, not necessarily the ones I’d recommend to just anybody new to her work, but my personal favorites. And my personal bottom five, just for balance.
CJ Cherryh’s Greatest Hits:
1. The Chanur series. Love it. Aliens and action and spaceships and complicated politics, and actually I think you can see Cherryh’s growth as a writer when you compare the first three with the fourth that was written later (Chanur’s Legacy).
2. Cuckoo’s Egg. The reason I didn’t put this in my “Great aliens” post is because the point of the story is not to make the aliens alien, exactly. Culturally they are distinctive, but psychologically they are imo quite human, and deliberately so. But it’s a great book, a standalone, short, with an intimate feel, truly one of my all-time favorite stories.
3. The Foreigner series. Okay, I love it, but I wouldn’t really suggest someone new to Cherryh start with a fifteen book series. Hah hah hah. No. But it is one of my favorites. Here’s Ann Leckie’s comments about the first book, which clearly explains both why I love this series and why I wouldn’t expect it to work for just everybody.
4. Paladin. This is one of Cherryh’s fantasies, one set in an alternate China.
This is a wonderful story, very closely focused on just one POV character. My guess is it would probably seem too slow to some readers, but I love the day-to-day feel of the story. Actually, in some ways it reminds me of A Stranger to Command by Sherwood Smith — both emphasize day-to-day detail of military training. Anyway, Goodreads says: “Now betrayed by the Emperor he once protected, master swordsman Saukendar leaves the way of the sword behind him forever–so he thinks. When a headstrong peasant girl burning to avenge her murdered family demands that he train her, Saukendar is faced with a momentous choice. Send Taizu away, never see her again–or join her and destroy the tyrant who has nearly destroyed them both.” This is basically true, although the story opens years after Saukendar retires from the world.
5. Cyteen. I’ve re-read this one a bunch of times, though I must admit I skip ahead till young Ari appears. I loved the sequel, too, though for me Regenesis was all about watching Justin and Grant and Ari and everyone get their lives in order and only a tiny bit about actually finding out who initially killed the older Ariane Emory.
The bottom of Cherryh’s barrel:
5. Forty Thousand in Gehenna. Watching the slow-motion destruction of the society established on Gehenna is just rather painful, especially since we see a good many people live not very pleasant lives during that part, so the whole first two-thirds of the book are not a very enjoyable read, at least not for me. I liked it better once we skip forward to the new, altered society that eventually grows out of colony.
4. Wave Without a Shore. Too weird for me, or something. It’s been a long time. Maybe I should try it again. But the fact that I’ve never re-visited it says something right there.
3. Brothers of Earth. There’s putting your protagonist through hell, and then there’s putting your protagonist through hell. I can see some of the ideas from this book echoing forward into later work, the whole throw-one-human-into-an-alien-society thing that Cherryh returns to again and again, but imo the Faded Sun trilogy was so much better.
2. Faery in Shadow. Caithe mac Sliabhan is under a curse that can’t be broken, only sort of slanted to be a little less cruel. The whole thing is just too grim for me.
1. The Rusalka series. I read the first book, didn’t like it, bought the second book, never actually picked it up off the shelf, and eventually gave them away. This was Cherryh’s only Total Failure for me, since I did keep all the rest of her books, even those I haven’t re-read. Now I’m sort of inclined to go back to Wave Without A Shore. Maybe I’d like it better now.
How about you all? If you’re a CJC fan, what are your top and bottom picks? Are they totally different from mine?
Remember, if you can’t comment in the ordinary way, just email me at email@example.com
Elaine T says: Way up at the top of the bottom list is DOWNBELOW STATION. It never worked for me. But I keep it because stuff in it is central to so much of her other sf.
Agree on Faery in Shadow. A friend of mine on a mailing list that CJC participated in swears the author thought FiS was a comedy, BTW. My friend and I agree that we don’t see how. Voyager in Night & Port Eternity, Brothers of Earth and the Hunter thing. Hestia.
Ones I revisit or that haunt me:
SF: Finity’s End, Rimrunners, 40K (I think I’m trying to understand it….) CYTEEN, CHANUR (all of it), WAVE WITHOUT A SHORE, parts of Foreigner, but not all of it, FADED SUN TRIPOINT, FORGE OF HEAVEN (maybe for the fashionistas).
Fantasy: Paladin, Goblin Mirror, FORTRESS (all but ICE which I pretend never happened), RIDER/Finisterre (I know it’s a planetary colony, but it reads like a Western crossed with sf/f elements, ok?), assorted short stories like THE LAST TOWER and a couple from Sunfall… The Teen was really taken by the Rusalka trilogy and I’ve had to reread it recently to be able to discuss it with her as she wants – it’s better than I remembered, and the last book definitely improved with her rewriting it. OTOH, said Teen has also created a Character Irrationality Scale and named it for one of the Rusalka characters who is extremely irrational.
And at this moment I’m rereading SERPENT’S REACH.
Me: I love the phrase “At the top of the bottom list.” Yep, that’s how I feel about 40 Thousand in Gehenna. And in fact I feel pretty much the same way about Downbelow Station, too. I see you didn’t limit yourself to five: that’s cheating!
I really like the Faded Sun trilogy and The Goblin Mirror; actually I also really like Voyager in Night and Hunter of Worlds (not so much Port Eternity, but I don’t hate it). Ugh, I’d forgotten about ICE, which I also pretend never appeared and is definitely on my bottom-five list, but I love the rest of the Fortress series.
A comedy, seriously? I don’t get that any more than you.
And I love love love the idea of a Character Irrationality Scale, but I don’t plan to re-read Rusalka in order to peg it to the irrational character in that one. I could use Julie from Set This House in Order, though.
11 thoughts on “Another look at CJ Cherryh —”
Way up at the top of the bottom list is DOWNBELOW STATION. It never worked for me. But I keep it because stuff in it is central to so much of her other sf.
Agree on Faery in Shadow. A friend of mine on a mailing list that CJC participated in swears the author thought FiS was a comedy, BTW. My friend and I agree that we don’t see how.
Voyager in Night & Port Eternity, Brothers of Earth and the Hunter thing. Hestia.
Ones I revisit or that haunt me:
SF: Finity’s End, Rimrunners, 40K (I think I’m trying to understand it….) CYTEEN, CHANUR (all of it), WAVE WITHOUT A SHORE, parts of Foreigner, but not all of it, FADED SUN TRIPOint, FORGE OF HEAVEN (maybe for the fashionistas).
Fantasy: Paladin, Goblin mirror, FORTRESS (all but ICE which I pretend never happened), RIDER/Finisterre (I know it’s a planetary colony, but it reads like a Western crossed with sf/f elements, ok?), assorted short stories like THE LAST TOWER and a couple from Sunfall… The Teen was really taken by the Rusalka trilogy and I’ve had to reread it recently to be able to discuss it with her as she wants – it’s better than I remembered, and the last book definitely improved with her rewriting it. OTOH, said Teen has also created a Character Irrationality Scale and named it for one of the Rusalka characters who is extremely irrational.
And at this moment I’m rereading SERPENTs REACH.
I expect to be alone in my love for the Finisterre books. ;) Otherwise, my top list includes, hmm, FINITY’S END, RIMRUNNERS, CHANUR, and PALADIN. Though I really love all the Merchanter books.
I last read 40K IN GEHENNA in high school and had very bad memories of it then. I’m currently trying to read BROTHERS OF EARTH and PORT ETERNITY but not making much headway in either of them. And I already confessed to my difficulties with HEAVY TIME. I feel like I ought to like it, I just can’t get through!
Well, you’re making me kinda want to re-read the Finisterre duology just to enjoy the horses. Though it is hard to tolerate everyone’s working hard to save that girl when *I* would just drop her off a cliff and say Oops, she slipped.
For so many of Cherryh’s books, it’s like we need a Claustrophobia Scale. One a scale of one to ten, how claustrophobic does this book make you feel? Rimrunners is about an eight. Heavy Time is about a nine. It’s not that I’m actually claustrophobic, btw, it’s that it’s painful to have characters trapped in a situation they can’t get out of. Which Cherryh handles by changing the situation so that it’s tolerable. But it can make the story hard to read, at least for me.
I’m still working my way through Cherryh’s backlist (good grief, so many books!). So far, my favorites are definitely the Foreigner books, although I did like Angel With the Sword a good deal. And wanted more in that world, which there doesn’t seem to be! Rusalka, yeah. No.
>And wanted more in that world, which there doesn’t seem to be!
Hah, little do you know! There are a huge number of shared world anthologies in the Angel With a Sword world, with Cherryh writing many of the stories. If you’re interested, search for “Merovingen Nights” rather than “Angel With a Sword”. The first is Festival Moon, the second Fever Season, and after that I’m not sure, but there are at least seven or eight or nine volumes.
WHAT WHAT WHAT!!
Cuckoo’s Egg is at the top of my list, one of my favorite books ever, even if I do cry through half of it. The Foreigner series because I love the aliens, the numbers, and politics – although she sure puts Bren through hell. The Chanur series for all the different aliens. Tripoint and Finity’s End if I want to wallow in anxt, which sometimes you need a good book for!
On the bottom, Serpent’s Reach and Forty Thousand in Gehenna don’t quite work for me, although I have read both more than once. I want to like Finisterre, but I find them a little too creepy.
Somehow I’ve never gotten around to reading Cyteen, The Paladin or Angel with the Sword, must add them to my to read list!
Yep. Enjoy! I definitely like some of the contributing authors better than others, but still, I’ve re-read the whole set at least once.
I think Cuckoo’s Egg is one of my favorites for all books ever, too. When you get around to Cyteen, I promise, it takes off when Young Ari appears! I love Paladin so much, so I hope you get to it soon and agree!
I actually quit Paladin halfway through, because the alternate-China setting just was not working for me. It was like all the setting detail was in place but the characters were getting played by Westerners. They just weren’t thinking in ways that said “Asian” to me. One example being the main character’s atheism. Atheism just wasn’t a thing for any primitive society—they might believe the gods ignored them or hated them but not that they didn’t exist. It’s been long enough that I don’t recall the other details, but I do remember thinking this sounded much more like a book about a European than an Asian person.
Hmm. Well, to me, it was “alternate” enough that it didn’t actually read too much like China, which is probably why it worked for me.